Sunday School: A Realistic Look at the 2023 Dodgers
It’s time for some Sunday School, Boys, and Girls, and I have a few observations, including what the Dodgers need to do for a SS, CF’er, and a six-man rotation in 2023. It’s time for some Sunday School Education. JD Martinez : The fact that the Dodgers signed J..D. Martinez…

It’s time for some Sunday School, Boys, and Girls, and I have a few observations, including what the Dodgers need to do for a SS, CF’er, and a six-man rotation in 2023. It’s time for some Sunday School Education.
- JD Martinez: The fact that the Dodgers signed J..D. Martinez means two things: (1) Max Muncy will play 3B while JD plays his best position – DH; and when Muncy DH’s Miguel Vargas plays 3B, but otherwise, he will be in LF. I doubt that J.D. plays the field much… if at all. I have heard from multiple sources that Justin Turner was susceptible to the fastball last year, and they expect it to get worse this year as he will be fed a steady diet of them. JDM has a close relationship with RVS, and while JD is no longer the slugger he used to be, I think RVS helps him have a stellar season.
- Gavin Lux: I think he is ready to break out as a 2B. He should lead off and use that speed. He could be an All-Star. Friedman will not let him play SS. That could derail his whole career. Watch and learn. Someone else will play SS… not Gavin. I’ll tell you who shortly.
- Miguel Vargas: He could play 3B or LF. If the Dodgers just let Miguel learn LF, he will be fine and in the running for ROY.
- Brett Anderson: He wants to come back, and I would endorse it (but not to the Dodgers) because if Trevor Bauer is re-instated, I’d love to see him bitchslap that fat ^%$*# all over the field.
- Dustin May: Why do so many of you look at last year and think his troubles in coming back will just continue? He missed over a year! He was rusty! He is young. That is typical! Give him Spring Training and some games into the season, and he will be fine. I see 12 wins and a 3.20 ERA.
- Thor: I see a guy who wants to resurrect his career. he was OK (merely) last season. He does not need to throw 98 to be successful – he needs to learn to pitch better (maybe a new pitch), and the Dodgers are the ones to teach him that. I predict 18 wins and a 2.70 ERA. He is going to win a lot of games slotted at #5.
- Tony Gonsolin: Unless he is really injured, I expect the same kind of season as last year. He’s not a workhorse, but especially with an aging Kershaw in the rotation, I could see him flourishing in a six-man starting staff. I don’t know what Urias would think about that. Maybe six days would keep Clayton healthy all season. I think it has to be a consideration. I would look for the six-man rotation by May.
- Dansby Swanson: I got the feeling the Dodgers thought Dansby was a nice player and would have signed him for something that amounted to stealing him, but now he is a Cub. If anyone thought Friedman was going to give up picks and International SB Money, they were greatly mistaken! He is building for the future every day!
- Chris Taylor: The Dodgers could do worse than have CT3 at SS. He was coming off elbow surgery last year, and without the shift, I look for him to have a better year offensively. He’s not Ozzie Smith, but he’s solid and has a good arm that should be better a year removed from surgery. Let’s not forget that in 2021 CT3 had 507 ABs (that’s “Regular Status”) with 20 HR, and 13 SBs (caught once), with a .254 BA and .344 OB%. Why could his bad year in 2022 not be related to his elbow surgery and rehab? The more I think about it, the more I see CT3 as the SS in 2023. CT3 would be a solid choice at SS. Lux might be Gold Glove at 2B, Freeman is close at 1B, and CT3 ain’t a chump. Max Muncy is merely average. I can live with that.
- Trevor Bauer: I heard from what I consider a reliable source that Trevor Bauer will have his entire suspension overturned and here is something as ridiculous as it sounds, the Dodgers will be on the hook for all his salary- even though he was not playing. That does not seem right to me, and the Dodgers may file a Grievance. However, that is part of the reason the Dodgers have been quiet. We shall see if my source is reliable.
From Chris Taylor’s own lips: “I would love to play short and center, (but) haven’t even had that conversation or thought about it at this point. We’re still early in the offseason. A lot can happen. Shortstop always has been my favorite position, so that would be exciting if I got to play some shortstop. And outfield is outfield to me. Left field, center, right, it’s kind of all the same.”
Look at this lineup and my projections:
- Lux 2B – .290 – 14 HR – 30- SB
- Betts RF – 290 – 35 HR – 18 SB
- Freeman 1B – .310 – 25 HR
- Smith C – .275 – 30 HR
- Muncy 3B – .255 – 35 HR (this is what Muncy usually does… what’s not to like about that? )
- Martinez DH – .290 – 20 HR/35 DBL
- Vargas LF – 275 – 20 HR 15 SB
- Taylor SS – .260 – 18 HR 20 SB
- Outman/Thompson CF (combined) – .240 BA – 25 HR – 25 SB
I would argue that the above lineup could very well be better than the 2022 lineup!
The Dodgers re-set the Luxury Tax and are getting ready for three more years of driving it up. The bench consists of Barnes, Hernandez, Amaya, Outman (or Thompson, depending on the day), and another player, like Busch, Vivas, or Leonard. The numbers I have assigned are aggressive but not crazy. I think Miguel Vargas can get out of bed and hit .275. Muncy and CT3 are healthy – they will both do better. Will Smith and Gavin Lux will keep growing, and the Dodger’s six-man rotation may be the best in baseball.
The Dodgers might look at Bryan Reynolds (or Michael A Taylor), but I think they try “in-house options first.” Notice I have not even mentioned Jason Heyward? I expect nothing, but you never know. We saw what happened with Matt Kemp for a half-season when everyone thought he was done. Kemp was never as fit as Heyward, so we just have to wait and see.
A lot of things would have to go right, but I can still see this team beating the Padres… again!

More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer
I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12
3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)
It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor
I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

Discussion (74)
Disagree, not disagreeable
I was catching up on Fangraphs today (hadn’t read it in a couple of weeks) and Eric A Longenhagen had this to say about Jeter Downs:
Became apparent in the upper levels that he could not get on top of high fastballs and he couldn’t adjust once the book was out
Then he was asked this: Do you think gavin lux playable at shortstop? What about muncy at 2nd with thr new shift rules?
His Answer:
No to both, IMO
I mean, I think even Ray Charles can see that. With JDM, Muncy goes to 3B, where (if you leave him alone) he will be serviceable. He will work hard to be above average and Taylor is better at SS than Lux. Ray saw that!
Welcome to Dodger Rehabilitation Center, ,where we’ll fix your swing or pitching mechanics if you’ll sign a one year deal and move on to another club the next year for more money. These shorter deals benefit the Dodgers on a shorter term basis while we wait for Dodger potential prospects to take their place.
If Bauer’s suspension is completely overturned it would seem only fair that the commissioners office would be where Bauer’s back pay should come. Single handedly Manfred is the cause of mishandling this affair and his position is to have fairness maintained in baseball. He has failed and needs to be held accountable. Handicapping a team franchise by overstepping his power is worse than Rose betting on baseball as it not only had major impact crippling Dodgers business wise it changed what could of been. Manfred set the world on a different path. He is not good for the game.
Coming into the off-season, I wanted a veteran toolsy bat on a short term to replace Trea’s spot in the lineup and narrowed it down to Martinez, Abreu, or Votto. At 10 million and 1 year, Martinez might be the best deal. Now we can continue to trot out five batters who are not three outcome hitters vs staggering them with Muncy or Swanson. I’m definitely more optimistic now about our chances next season because of this.
I’ll be shocked if Lux isn’t the opening day SS. Lux is not my personal choice, but Roberts mentions his name first as next man on deck and I think they’ll want to at least audition him thru the early season. I don’t know if they’ll keep him at 9th in the order, but I liked him there. Gives our reigning HR leader -Mookie- more at-bats with someone on base. Plus, the less pressure on Lux the better. He’ll have enough on his plate re-adjusting to SS. I worry about Taylor’s range as a full time SS without the shift protection. I worry about his ability to hit the fastball now. I’d be planning to phase Taylor out at this point, not give him a bigger role. Maybe I’m being too pessimistic on him, but the creeping age has my spidey senses on alert.
I’m bullish on the rookies though. I think Vargas will need 400 at bats to find his groove and hopefully they just let him grind thru it. Expect Outman to be streaky, but the hot stretches will forgive a lot. I think Busch has the most major league ready bat, will have the best numbers at year end. Once they insert him, he’ll give them reasons not to take him out. At worst, he’ll hopefully push Muncy to perform. I’m optimistic on May and Gonsolin as well. I expect they’ll give Stone the same show-us-what-you-got test White, Jackson, Pepiot got last year, but I think he’ll pass. He’ll show the best command keeping the pitch count low and he’ll get K’s with the changeup. I don’t think we’ll see Miller until the 2nd half.
See, it all came together. Don’t shell out those long contracts unless you’re the best of the best and fairly injury free.
I freaking love JDM on a one-year deal! He’s 35 next year, look for a bounce back. He loves SVS! He’s a better fit in the order than Trea. Objectively a model cleanup hitter! Too soon, Bluto?
Lux will be at SS. We’ll see who’s right.
Eric is right, Busch will have to earn his job.
Vargas in LF is more scary than Lux at SS for me. Hell, Muncy at 2nd or 3rd is more scary than Lux at SS.
This lineup will be better than last year’s lineup. Bank on it! Defense? Not so much.
Mark, you say that Bauer’s suspension will be overturned and then you say we’re going to reset. You gotta make a choice. They won’t both happen.
When you list your lineup and then the bench pieces, if I’m counting correctly you list 5 guys on the bench. We only get 4.
We’ve just signed Bradley Zimmer to a minor league deal. There’s your center fielder, especially if one of the prerequisites for the job is that the center fielder can’t hit.
Mark thanks again for putting my mind at ease again with your wisdom. I did post that I would like to get Jean Segura type player for so but your idea of using CT3 at that position makes a lot of sense. He personally has said I believe more than once that he prefers to play shortstop. Problem solved.
I’m exhausted after watching my hometown Bills beat Miami in the snow, but I will share one thought from your article- YES, YES, YES….CT3 at SS and not Lux makes me feel better. Keeping Lux at 2B makes me sleep easier too.
Okay with that I’m out of here. ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
TM
Beat the Padres again? Every month but October!