SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Who Should Be The Dodgers Catcher?

Lert me start all this by saying that I was TOTALLY in favor of the Dee Gordon trade. I thought Austin Barnes and Kike Hernandez would be very good players. FAZ parlayed Andrew Heaney into Howie Kendrick who played a nice role for the Dodgers a couple of years ago and even though Chris Hatcher was a bust as a Dodger, I would still do that trade in a New

By Mark Timmons3 min readJump to 89 comments

Lert me start all this by saying that I was TOTALLY in favor of the Dee Gordon trade.  I thought Austin Barnes and Kike Hernandez would be very good players.  FAZ parlayed Andrew Heaney into Howie Kendrick who played a nice role for the Dodgers a couple of years ago and even though Chris Hatcher was a bust as a Dodger, I would still do that trade in a New York minute.

Kike Hernandez is two year younger than Austin and (some of you will make fun of me for saying this), but I think Kike will eventually hit 30 HR a season in this league. He has issues against RH pitching, but maybe that can be improved upon as he matures.  He has excellent power and is younger than Chris Taylor.  I think he will have a breakout year as soon as next year! However, I digress… Who should be the Dodgers Catcher?

Many of you think Austin Barnes should take Yasmani’s place and while we don’t lose a lot when Austin is the Catcher, you need to consider this:

  • When Barnes catches the Dodgers have a 3.75 ERA.

  • When Grandal catches the Dodgers have a 3.20. ERA. That’s a half run less a game!

  • Yasmani has thrown out 32% of baserunners who try and steal, while Austin only gets 20%.

  • Austin Barnes fielding PCT is .992. Yasmani’s is .995.

  • Grandal has 6 errors in twice as many innings as Barnes (4).

  • The only area Barnes is better is Passed Balls. Grandal has 15 while Barnes has only 3 in half as many innings.

However, Grandal is one of the TOP 3 Pitch Framers in the game and the dude does have 22 HR in what I consider a down year for him.
As long a pitch framing is a thing, Yasmani will be the primary catcher… unless his offensive production becomes a liability. The passed balls are the byproduct of moving his glove in framing. It pays off, however!

This year, the Dodgers have Logan Forsythe at 2B, but they could trade him or pay him $1 Million to walk and save $7.5 Million NEXT year.  Logan Forsythe is a very good defensive 2B, but has been disappointing against RHP.  Next year, I would move Austin Barnes to 2B – he’s a very good 2B as well and his arm would play better at 2B than behind the plate.

I think Austin Barnes is a .300 hitter if he plays every day. He is a very good, but not GREAT catcher. We need to enjoy this run of the 2017 Dodgers, because next year, the team will look very different.  There are lots of directions te team could go, but Forsythe, Ethier and Granderson won’t be on the roster.  Adrian may well be forced to retire with his back… or maybe the Dodgers could work out a personal services contract with him to be the face of the Dodgers as Tommy fades.

Talent wise, Alex Verdugo is in the same category as Seager and Bellinger (except for power).  The mental aspect of his game is what will determine how good he becomes.  He could very well be the 2018 Rookie of the Year. Right about now though, the Playoff Roster is Paramount.  Look for a surprise… maybe two. Just say “NO” to El Gasolino!

The Dodgers now have 102 wins and are starting to get “White Hot” again.  Maybe Doc’s strategy is working and they have flipped the switch.  One more win and they set the all-time LA Dodger record for wins.  One more win and they clinch home-field advantage throughout the playoffs. After Sunday, all they need are 11 more wins. Man, Rich Hill is pitching like Kershaw and Darvish and Alex Wood is not pleased with the possibility of going to the pen.  I would not want him to be, but Just Bloom Where You Are Planted, Alex!

Photo Credit: Dodgers.com and MLB 

It’s Go Time!

Discussion (89)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. Watford DodgerSeptember 30, 2017

    Very disappointing result.

    This is what I would do now.

    Kershaw goes tonight, and hopefully we can get the one win necessary to secure home field all the way.

    To me, this has become imperative. We are a much better team at Chavez Ravine. Absolute no brainer to ensure that advantage.

    If CK doesn’t get it done tonight then F##k the Bullpen Game on Sunday, throw the ball to Darvish & tell him to get the job done.

    Colorado will have secured the other Wild Card spot & may have a BP game themselves, or at least be in celebratory mood. Darvish won’t pitch before next Saturday (7 days) at the earliest, possibly 9 days if he pitches game 3. He probably would prefer the work anyway.

    I will be absolutely pissed if we don’t do everything we can to secure the #1 seed.

  2. Tim RobinsonSeptember 30, 2017

    Hmm. Tanking maybe. Rox Snakes one game play in. Maybe the Dodgers are pushing the Rox in hopes they beat the Snakes.

    Lots of ideas and scenarios can happen.

  3. dodgerrickSeptember 30, 2017

    Here’s the deal – the Dodgers scored 28 runs in 3 games against the Padres that didn’t mean anything.

    Now the Dodgers stink the place up in a game that doesn’t mean anything (to them).

    Indians beat the Chisox 10 – 1 in a game that doesn’t mean anything.

    I am concerned that the Dodgers can’t just “flip the switch”. The 3 games against SD didn’t prove anything. Does the game tonight prove anything? No. But has the “switch been flipped”?

    NO

  4. Rudy ByrdSeptember 30, 2017

    One run in 7 innings against a nothing pitcher with a +5 ERA and playing in Coors Field should raise a bright red flag. Wait until we face a good pitcher. Yikes.

  5. Brooklyn Dodge rSeptember 30, 2017

    Is it my imagination, or is Cory Bellinger trying too hard to hit #40? Seems to me that he’s over-swinging a lot.

  6. Brooklyn Dodge rSeptember 30, 2017

    Since the first time I saw him, I’ve been concerned that Buehler’s fastball is as straight as an arrow. I need to see more movement before I’m convinced. Just hope he doesn’t turn out to be another Josh Ravin. He’s a lot younger, so there’s time.

  7. dodgerrickSeptember 30, 2017

    El Gasolino to enter. That will fix everything.

    They’ve flipped the switch back on? Really?

  8. dodgerrickSeptember 30, 2017

    Another PB for Grandal

  9. dodgerrickSeptember 30, 2017

    Ryu – no to the post-season?

    Buehler – welcome to Coors Field

  10. Brooklyn Dodge rSeptember 30, 2017

    Is anyone surprised that Ryu is getting lit up? His stuff just doesn’t play well at Coors. And coming off an injury doesn’t help.

  11. Rudy ByrdSeptember 30, 2017

    You can add Ryu to the ever-growing list of Baez, Font, McCarthy, Maeda, Ravin, Stewart,and Stripling, to the list of pitchers currently on the 40 man staff that I hope I don’t have to see next year in a Dodgers uniform.

  12. HawkeyeDodgerSeptember 29, 2017

    Tonight’s lineup:

    Granderson-CF

    Seager-SS

    Turner-3B

    Belli-1B

    Puig-RF

    Ethier-LF

    Grandal-C

    Forsythe-2B

    Ryu-P

    Other than the leadoff man I like it.

  13. HawkeyeDodgerSeptember 29, 2017

    Dodgers called up Locastro. Remember when the carried to Dee Gordon to pinch-run?

  14. Watford DodgerSeptember 29, 2017

    I think the Dodgers trade Grandal this offseason, while he still has value.

  15. GonzoSeptember 29, 2017

    Adrian can’t play anymore. I would love it it if he could. He’s a great role model for young Latino kids everywhere. I know that a playing contract can’t be transferred to the front office and I forgot to mention good old Loyd’s of London. I wish I could like Verdugo’s game, I just don’t. If he were to stay on the team and contribute, of course like every hypocritical fan I would support him, but my gut tells me he won’t be in LA. I don’t have a direct pipeline but still know people in the travel team business that tell me he’s as obnoxious as ever. From what I was told, Roberts tore him a new one after he was late to a practice or game.

  16. QuasimodoSeptember 29, 2017

    I don’t think Verdugo is aware TEAM isn’t spelled IEAM…..yet. Potential poison so don’t pen him on the roster until he makes that adjustment.

  17. blutoSeptember 29, 2017
    Open on www.cbssports.comhttps://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/keri-the-10-dont-sleep-on-astros-its-miller-time-for-price-and-more-mlb-notes/

    .

    Jonah Keri on why the Dodgers should be optimistic:

    .

    Three simple reasons:

    First, the Dodgers feature the best quartet of starting pitchers among all playoff teams, with Clayton Kershaw backed by Yu Darvish and highly underrated lefties Rich Hill and Alex Wood.

    .

    Second, the Dodgers have addressed their bullpen woes in a more effective manner than we’ve seen in years. Kenley Jansen remains a superelite closer capable of dominating in both the regular season and postseason. But Brandon Morrow, Tony Cingrani, and Luis Avilan lead a revamped batch of setup and middle men who miss tons of bats and perplex opposing hitters with their many different looks.

    .

    Third, the Dodgers trotted out the most potent attack in the National League this year, with slugging rookie Cody Bellinger complementing Corey Seager and Justin Turner in a deep offense that’s even dangerous off the bench.

    .

    And finally, momentum means nothing. Specifically, how a ballclub fares in September has no correlation with how it will fare in October (once you adjust for other variables, such as the overall quality of said teams).

    .

    The Dodgers were an excellent bet to challenge for their first World Series in 29 years before they recently came unglued for a few weeks. They remain excellent bets to do so even after that rough patch.

  18. Mark TimmonsSeptember 29, 2017

    It seems like every spring some young player “seizes the day.”

    Who will it be next year:

    Verdugo?

    Rios?

    Ramos?

    Buehler?

    White?

    Locastro?

    Who? I want to know NOW!

  19. IdahoalSeptember 29, 2017

    You know if Rios can play first, Bellinger could play any position in the outfield. Also if a good SS comes along, Seager could certainly play third. Taylor can play second. So many different options.

  20. Eric NelsonSeptember 29, 2017

    The Dodgers need a #5 hitter. I too believe both Puig and Pederson will be gone. They need a bat like J.D. Martinez has provided for Arizona; average plus power. Do any of their minor leaguers fit that bill? Do they have something like that in the pipeline or will they be trading for that piece? I would like Yelich in center, Taylor in left, and Toles in right. But Yelich is not quite the 30 HR guy that they need.

  21. Mark TimmonsSeptember 29, 2017

    I got Baseball America’s TOP 10 PROSPECTS of the minors today.

    Walker Buehler is on the cover and was named the #1 prospect in the Texas League. They say he projects “at least” as a No. 2 Starter.

    Edwin Rios was the #8 prospect in AA Texas League and was called the “best pure hitter in the Texas League.” His only spot is 1B.

    Alex Verdugo was the #4 prospect in the PCL and was called “one of the most disciplined young batters.” Unlike me, they think he has enough speed to play CF!

    They call Mitch White a “solid No 2 or No 3 with excellent stuff.”

  22. IdahoalSeptember 28, 2017

    I think we will see Toles, Taylor and Verdugo in the outfield. Good speed all the way around. Pretty good arms. Puig will be traded. Beuhler will be a starter. He will replace Darvish. Pederson is gone. Barnes will play second. These are all guesses. That is all we can do looking at next season. A fun time. I can see one to two farm kids making the team each year.

  23. GonzoSeptember 28, 2017

    Verdugo doesn’t pass the smell test for me. There is something shady about him that I have never liked way back when I saw him play HS baseball. He will be packaged along with Puig in a trade this off season. AGon needs to be the laureate batting coach a la Bill Muellar who was paid his player salary as an executive so it wouldn’t count as team payroll. I think the Dodgers are going to be better next year. We just need 2a and 2b starters. Enough with the McCarthy and Kazmir experiments. I’d even consider trading Alex Wood while his value is high. I like him a lot, but I think he will break down soon. I think that Stanton to the LA has legs and is doable if FLA picks up some salary and Stanton defers some money. He can then get traded to an AL team to DH. While I’m glad the Dodgers are white hot I’m not to excited it was the Padres. If it would have been the D-wacks, I’d feel a little better.

More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer

I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

By Mark Timmons · July 17, 202673

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12

3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

By Jeff Dominique · July 16, 202674

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)

It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

By Mark Timmons · July 15, 202652

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor

I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · July 14, 202676