SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

What If?

What if the Dodgers had traded Gavin Lux, DFA’ed CT3, and cut Kike Hernandez like many fans were begging them to do? Boy, are we glad the fans were not running the team! What if the Dodgers had traded Miguel Rojas? In many ways, he has been the glue! What if David Bednar was the…

By Mark Timmons3 min read15 comments
  • What if the Dodgers had traded Gavin Lux, DFA’ed CT3, and cut Kike Hernandez like many fans were begging them to do? Boy, are we glad the fans were not running the team!
  • What if the Dodgers had traded Miguel Rojas? In many ways, he has been the glue!
  • What if David Bednar was the Dodgers closer? Fickle is what closers are!
  • What if Garret Crochet was acquired to be the Ace? An Ace who can’t pitch...
  • What if CJ Abrams was the Dodgers shortstop? Would he help in the future? Maybe, but not in a Pennant Race… Rojas is much better!
  • What if Miguel Vargas were the Dodgers LF’er? He has been an unmitigated disaster!
  • What if Michael Busch were still on the team? Where would he play?
  • What if River Ryan, Nick Frasso, Emmet Sheehan, Tony Gonsolin, Kyle Hurt, and Dustin May (torn esophagus? WTF!) were healthy? The Dodgers are doing a deep dive into the cause of all these pitcher injuries. I don’t know all the particulars but I would imagine that they are bringing in consultants and medical experts to evaluate it.
  • What if chickens had lips? They would be people!

What if, what if? I prefer “What Is?” One of my favorite sayings is this:

You have to play the hand you are dealt. Yamamoto will be back next week. The Bazooka is also close. Clayton and Tyler Glasnow are farther away, and Bobby Miller is closer than you think. Many fans are calling him a head case because he is very demonstrable on the mound. Let me remind you that many great pitchers were not stoic! I have no problem with that, and to say he is a “head case” is assuming facts that are not in evidence. There’s a fine line between Saturday Night and Sunday Morning. There’s also a fine line between genius and insanity and success and failure. Bobby’s four-seamer is a little off. It’s all fixable and fixable very quickly. It could be cause by his knee… or not. It may happen just like he flipped a switch. He did strike out eight last night, and it was the first inning where he gave up five runs before he struck out the side that did him in.

He gave up two runs in the next four innings. I guess you can see a glass as half empty or half full… I am telling you that Bobby Miller is close! It is always darkest right before dawn. I think there is a pretty good chance that Bobby Miller is nails come playoff time. The bazooka will likely be back on Friday with Pederson going back to OKC. Kershaw and Glasnow are possibly due back around the middle of the month. We shall see, but the Dodgers do not need everyone to be healthy. Just a few.

What is IS, even with the lopsided loss? That was the Angels World Series! Move on, there’s nothing to see here, Folks!

X-CITES

https://twitter.com/DrEliDavid/status/1831410510082011436

Next week is a busy week for me. I have to fly to St. George, Utah, for business Monday – Thursday, and we have a busy weekend keeping my sons’ two kids. I live for this:

Discussion (15)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. Mark TimmonsSeptember 6, 2024

    This months audition for the playoffs has 4 Acts. Tomorrow, Act I will be done, but there are still 3 more weeks to determine who will be there in the playoffs. I see fans say, “Well, Miller gets one more start.” No, he doesn’t – that’s what morons say. Whenever they jump to conclusions, they are usually wrong. You have to let it play out. Tonight we will see if Landon can get the Knack.

  2. Jorge ValenzuelaSeptember 6, 2024

    It was a beautiful swing, it made my day!

  3. M. NorrisSeptember 6, 2024

    Padres lost a stunner, 4-3 when Detroit had a rookie, Parker Meadows, hit a grand slam with 2 outs and 2 strikes on him. Az also lost. Lead is 4.5 over SD and 5.5 over Az. LA picked up a half game on both.

  4. Mark TimmonsSeptember 5, 2024

    Glasnow, Flaherty, Kershaw, Yamamoto, Buehler, Miller = Six Pitchers. We only need three!

    Gavin Stone is the Number Four… and then you have Landon Knack and the bullpen.

    I think we can find three!

  5. 4-GensSeptember 5, 2024

    Agree that we only need a few players to be healthy—Glasgow and Yamamoto. I believe the Dodgers go far if the pair can in top form as our 1-2. Stone is a good 3. Kersh, Buehler, Miller can likely give 4-5 innings , but will also give up 4-5 runs to the Padres or Phillies in a playoff game.

  6. DanoSeptember 5, 2024

    Hmm. It could be that Bobby was slightly tipping his heater. They seemed to be waiting on it. Maybe he only tips it sometimes. Just a little tiny twitch. You know your opponent did their homework and is just sitting on it. Usually you mix that heater with your secondary arsenal they don’t know it’s coming then you got em. But like you said Mark, shore up and smooth out that delivery, and he’s our man!

    Book em

  7. dodgerrickSeptember 5, 2024

    There have been lots of pitchers who have had good stuff and couldn’t get people out, and those who apparently don’t who can. I have never understood why that is, but it certainly is.

    Michael Grove is one of the former. Good crisp fastball usually well located, dynamite slider. Yet year after year, his numbers look the same – ERAs have been 4.60, 6.13, and 4.96 in his 3 years with the Dodgers. While its true that this is his first year as a full-time reliever, his numbers aren’t much better. (The peripherals are better though.)

    So is Bobby Miller one of these guys? The stuff if fantastic, he has a legit 5 pitch mix, and can run it up there 100. But his fastball is really hittable – SLG% against the 4-seamer is .656 and he has given up 9 HR in 93 AB against it.

    Miller is still young and all of that, but how could a fastball that averages nearly 98 MPH this year not be a better pitch than that?

    On the flip side of this is a guy like Clayton Kershaw. Even though his arm was hanging by a thread last year, he still won 13 games and pitched to a 2.46 ERA.

    How do you look into a guy’s head or heart to know if he is gonna be a guy who can figure out how to compete at the highest level or not?

  8. Shawn MurphySeptember 5, 2024

    Agreed on the wait and see – Miller has awesome stuff but seems unable to harness it.

    Progress is not linear – or something like that.

    I remember his game at the beginning of the season – where he was just dominant (6.0-IP, 2-H, 11-SO, 1-BB). No clue when he gets there again, but he does have the ability.

    Lux just keeps hitting – man, he tried all of our patience – happy for him. Average for the year is at .255 – which is crazy good compared to 2-months ago.

    I am OK with the Padres and D-back continued good play – we need them at this level to keep the Dodger’s focused so we can finally win the whole damn thing.

  9. dodgerdadSeptember 5, 2024

    in the first inning last night we had 2 Bobby Millers. the first one was not good. the 2nd one was outstanding! if he pitches like the 2nd one he’s gonna be hell on everyone! His fastball is 100mph and straight. With a little movement , and his outstanding breaking stuff he can be a number one on any team in baseball!

  10. davidSeptember 5, 2024

    Of all the ‘what ifs’ I would say that Miller is one that will figure it out

  11. MushersPopSeptember 5, 2024

    If Kershaw’s toe is chronic, can anyone be sure there will be no repeat of what happened the last time he pitched? Especially in the playoffs.?

    It didn’t sound like it was something treatable.

  12. DanoSeptember 5, 2024

    If your up against a pitcher throwing a masterpiece. Work the count. Foul balls off. Get him to the showers. If not wait for a mistake and pounce. Come Oct. you can’t give up multiple runs in the first. A few tweaks and get the mechanics straightened and Los Doyers will be flying high. I’m all in.

    Book em

  13. Brian PerkinsSeptember 5, 2024

    Busier than a one-armed paper hanger.

    More nervous than a long-tailed cat in a room full of rocking chairs.

    More confident than a one-legged high jumper.

  14. Andrew Vincent ForteSeptember 5, 2024

    Manager Dave Roberts said Wednesday that Yamamoto (triceps) will return from the injured list to start against the Cubs on Tuesday, David Vassegh of AM 570 LA Sports reports.

    “Yamamoto allowed three earned runs in four innings across his two rehab starts at Triple-A Oklahoma City, but the Dodgers seem to be comfortable clearing him to rejoin their rotation. The 26-year-old righty only reached 53 pitches during his most recent outing Tuesday, so it’s likely he’ll be working under a pitch/innings restriction as he makes his first start since June 15”.

  15. Andrew Vincent ForteSeptember 5, 2024

    The Dodgers begin a stretch of 16 games in 17 days on Friday, and Landon Knack will start that series opener against the Guardians at Dodger Stadium, Roberts also said Wednesday in Anaheim, per David Vassegh of Dodger Talk and Fabian Ardaya at The Athletic.

More from Dodger Talk

Nothing Wrong With Back of the Rotation SP for LAD

I said it when Roki Sasaki was struggling…If not Roki, who? He finally started to pitch with more confidence and he put together a string of positive starts. Yes, there were those who forgot about his previous four excellent starts and instead focused on his CWS start. He is a…

By Jeff Dominique · June 16, 202670

Who Bats Where?

A good percentage of comments on this blog relate to “who bats where” in the batting order. “Shohei should bat cleanup.” “ Freddie should be the number three hitter.” “No, Freddie should hit second.” “Max Muncy should hit cleanup.” “Mookie should hit 9th.” … and on and on… Where…

By Mark Timmons · June 15, 2026104

Happy, Hopeful, Blessed, and Thankful

I grew up in Ohio and lived there until 1976, when I was 23 years old. I have been in Indiana for 50 years, so I consider myself a Hoosier. Now, I actually live 45 minutes from Bloomington, where the IU Hoosiers play. However, since I was nine years old, I have been a Dodger…

By Mark Timmons · June 14, 2026123

Are You True Blue?

What do I mean by true blue? Well, over the years I have seen my share of bandwagon and fair-weather fans. True blue fans stick with the team no matter what. Their allegiance to the team never waivers. Not when a favorite is traded or lost to free agency, not when the team…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · June 13, 202693