What About the Platoons?
It has already been established by Doc Roberts that left field, first base and catcher will be manned by a platoon. Well, actually, catcher is not so much of a platoon but rather a way to keep Barnes from being overworked, so Russ Martin will catch about 3 days a week or something thereabouts. Since Right-Handers make up about 70% of the pitchers, that means that at 1B, Max Muncy

It has already been established by Doc Roberts that left field, first base and catcher will be manned by a platoon. Well, actually, catcher is not so much of a platoon but rather a way to keep Barnes from being overworked, so Russ Martin will catch about 3 days a week or something thereabouts.
Since Right-Handers make up about 70% of the pitchers, that means that at 1B, Max Muncy will play about 70% of the time and he can also fill-in for Justin Turner at 3B, like on Sunday, so Max will likely get close to 500 at-bats and David Freese will get plenty of rest. That brings us to LF and Joc Pederson platooning with Chris Taylor. Again, it looks like a pure platoon to me. Joc plays 70% of the time and CT3 plays 30% of the time as well as filling in for other resting or injured players.
CT3 can play LF, CF, SS and 2B at an above-average level, so he is now the Dodgers Swiss Army Knife! Kike Hernandez holds down the fort at 2B and I see him getting incrementally better… maybe not becoming JD Martinez, but possibly an All-Star.
Joc Pederson has started the season extremely hot (.467/.619/1.133 with 3 HR), after hitting .180 in Spring Training. Many fans were calling for his head at the end of the Pre-Season. Now, many want him to start against LH and RH pitching. I have no problem with that… except for the fact he has never been able to hit LHP. NEVER! Let’s look at his BA against LHP since his rookie year:
- 2014 – .000
- 2015 – .216
- 2016 – .125
- 2017 – .204
- 2018 – .170
- 2019 – .000
For his career, Joc hits .181 against LHP. Admittedly, it is a small sampling (288 AB’s verses 1,309 against RHP), but you have to demonstrate that you have a chance against lefties and Joc just has not done it. That could all magically change, of course, but I am not holding my breath.
I think the smart money is to let Joc hit against RHP, let his confidence build and then stir him in against an occasional LHP. Some LH hitters just cannot deal well with lefties. Andre Ethier hit .303 against RHP and .233 against LHP. His OB% was .382 against righties, but a mere .291 against lefties.
It is what it is. I would occasionally give Joc a chance against an weaker lefty, but for the most part, I want to put him in a position to succeed. He has demonstrated that he is not successful against lefties. Maybe RVS can fix that, but I am far from confident.
Joc looks like he is benefiting from the Dodgers new hitting approach and instructors. Let him do what he does. Don’t push the envelope. Give it time. Maybe he will grow into it, but pushing the envelope right now and allowing Joc to hit against LHP could really backfire. I like his confidence level. Let him play 70% of the time and build up the confidence more. Maybe Doc eases him in later to see how he does against lefties. That’s my take.
Last Night’s Debacle
When asked about Joe Kelly’s execution last night, Dave Roberts said “I’m all for it!” <That’s a sick joke.> The Dodgers are 3-2 and Joe Kelly caused both of those losses. His ERA sits at a cool 18.00. The Dodgers braintrust signed Kelly because they felt they could help him become even better with smoothing out some mechanical issues. That has not happened as yet!
We have to realize that when signing a player, one of three (3) things can happen… actually WILL happen:
- He will be better;
- He will be the same; or
- He will be worse.
So far, Joe Kelly has been horrible. There has to be some concern building as to whether he can turn it around. Right about now, he has to have ZERO confidence. Short term, the Dodgers have to keep him out of high-leverage situations. He is certainly capable of turning it around, but the longer it goes, the less likely it is. He has had this issue in the past, so there is a precedent for hoping for a turn-around. I do not second-guess much, but I thought that in this situation, Doc should not have brought Kelly out for a second inning after giving up a run in his first inning.
The good news is that others in the bullpen are looking better, namely Pedro Baez. The other good news is that the Dodgers have the resources in the minors, namely Gonsolin, Santana and Therrien. Some will suggest that Craig Kimbrel is the solution, but I happen to be of the opinion that his best days are behind him. I think other GM’s believe the same thing, which is why he remains unsigned. I would stay away from him. No “knee-jerk” reactions.
Milwaukee’s bullpen was very good last season with Woodruff and Burnes playing a big role. This year, they have been converted back to starters. I wish the Dodgers would consider that with Gonsolin and Santana.
After the game, Kelly said this:
“I don’t like it as much as everyone else doesn’t like it, especially coming over here on a new team. I don’t put any added pressure on myself, I just obviously feel bad for letting the guys down the first two times. It’s not going to happen 68 more times or however many times I pitch.I know I’m not even close to being myself results-wise. But today I felt a lot better. From here on out, hopefully if I continue with those mechanics and those pitches, the results will change.”
Rants and Raves
- It was good to see CT3 get untracked as part of that LF Platoon. That HR helped his confidence immensely.
- Who says Alex Verdugo has no power? I told you it would come. The Dodgers have confidence that he can hit LH pitching, so he pinch hit against a lefty. I believe this guy will eventually hit 30 HR. Where does he play? I think it will eventually be RF and Cody going back to 1B. There are so many options and possibilities.
- Joe Kelly may have blew the game, but the reality is: you will not win many games scoring just 2 runs. The good news is that it took the Dodgers 2 games last year to score two runs against the Giants. They have to hit better.
- I hate to say it, but if the Giants get lucky and stay healthy, they could be pretty good, like maybe over .500 good. Evan Longoria and Joe Panik look to be re-built and if Belt, Posey and Crawfish can stay healthy, the offense could surprise.
- The best news is that Julio Urias was beyond outstanding. This is why I was against trading him. So was Friedman. He is a potential Ace or with Striker here, “a Co-Ace“. Don’t count Kershaw out just yet, either. He wants that title too. I don’t see how you can put Urias back in the bullpen… maybe you just let him skip a few starts here and there, but he is a starter.
Photo Credit: Jon SooHoo/LA Dodgers
More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer
I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12
3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)
It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor
I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

Discussion (90)
Disagree, not disagreeable
And Urias has been through a lot in those two years while he has been recovering.
Many thought maybe his major league career was over, after hearing about his injury.
All of this, has not only made him mature even more, it has made him the pitcher he is right now.
It’s far too early to look at stats; let’s look at some stats.
Four batters are currently getting it done in a big way:
Joc–1.063 SLG%
Barnes–1.000 SLG%
Bellinger–.958 SLG%
Verdugo–1.000 SLG%
Before you shout SSS at me for Verdugo, he has only two fewer AB’s than Barnes. And here’s a bonus fact: While Barnes has a neat 2/0 BB/K, Verdugo has an even cleaner 0/0 one. These boys make contact.
Four batters are currently struggling: Seager, Muncy, Turner, & Taylor. At the request of the survivors, the numbers have been omitted. Out of respect for the dead, the rest has been told exactly as it occurred.
(Hernandez & Pollock have also been more than fine: .375/.450/.750 & .333/.417/.571 respectively
Pitching is even harder to do, as the starters have only gone once through in the rotation and, in relief, one bad outing can spoil an entire line. Obviously, the standout poor performers are Kelly & Stewart [the latter will be shipped out as soon as Kershaw’s ready] and Yimi & Baez [although Baez did two toss 2 scoreless IP last night].
The only starter who performed poorly is Buehler, who will hereby receive an official LADT Mulligan and be allowed to start his next game with a 0.00 ERA. Just waiting on the league to approve this. Mark, you might want to send Manfred a case of whiskey to grease the wheels if you can.
Management: Subjective, but Roberts appears to be up to his old tricks and the F.O. gave him the roster it gave him: no Harper, Ottovino, etc.
Checked in on the Madre this week and youngster P Lauer and Tatis Jr. They are a team to be reckoned in the future.
But we will overcome..
Tweet last night from Alex Pavlovic:
“Julio Urias is making his first start in nearly two years and he’s still three years younger than anyone on the Giants roster”
Mark, there is an older gentleman that sits almost directly in back of the catcher at Dodger Stadium He is always there, well dressed, dark rimmed glasses, and dark dyed hair with a deep tan. He is visible every pitch. Do you know who this person is?
Having too many position players is rarely a problem. That said, Muncy would be a near-perfect DH.
I think we can make this work but, yeah, I’d really like to see Verdugo get some regular AB’s without just waiting for an injury or for someone to play himself out of the lineup.
I’m guessing the F.O. has a timeline for how they’d like this to play out. Assuming we make the playoffs, the only thing that matters is who’s playing come October.
Bellinger is hitting much better than he did last year and although his hitting stance and swing look a lot like it did last year, RVS has done something to make Bellinger better. There were reports that Belli started early with RVS this winter. There was little written about Joc working with RVS though but I think Joc has made the most out of RVS’ tutelage.
Joc is clearly keeping his bat a lot longer in the hitting zone than he did last year and is now more consistently getting the barrel where it is supposed to be. He looks like he is thinking up the middle and then reacting to the pitch and either pulling or going with the pitch. Several of his home runs are to center and left field.
Joc has a different swing against lefties. He is keeping his front shoulder in more and looks like he wants to hit line drives up the middle against lefties. If he keeps that philosophy he could do much better against lefties this year. Joc might be giving Doc reason to not pinch hit for him if a lefty reliever comes in before the 6th inning, maybe the 7th inning. That would help the Dodgers by not pairing the righty/lefty match up too early and then have righty on righty in the last three or 4 innings.
There are a couple of locations pitchers can’t put the ball against Taylor or he will drill it. He seems to still have too many locations pitchers can put the ball though where he will struggle. It looks like the same is true for Muncy. Verdugo however is looking better and better. Freese didn’t look good to me in Spring Training and he still doesn’t. I think Beatty will take his spot next year.
I like Urias and Stripling in the rotation and this year it might be appropriate to go with a 6 man rotation. If the bullpen is a weakness it won’t be when someone in the rotation joins it and that will happen when Kershaw and Hill return.
I’m kidding Mark but maybe Baez has again moved ahead of Stewart on the bullpen ladder but has Kelly now dropped under Stewart? Is Kelly the new 25th man?
Kudos to you M.T. on the Verdugo comments… Let me preface this with I’m a big fan of Verdugo… He’s a AAAA player who ain’t going back to OKC and I wish they would give him the RF post and tell him it’s yours to lose… WE might be surprised…
Well, you don’t win too many games with 2 runs scored, that is true. But, I think I’ve heard this song before. 5 innings and 77 pitches, shutout going, just 3 base-runners in five innings. Time to pull him! That was the first mistake.
I feel bad for Kelly. He gave up that leadoff HR, fine. Then he proceeded to retire the next 3 guys, progress! Let’s build his confidence and send him out for a second inning. That was the second mistake. Really playing with fire here. Gotta make sure to use the least effective reliever the most. After a single and 2 outs with a runner at third, the fat guy gets lucky singles off a pitch at his ankles. That probably would be a good time to call it a night, but no…a double to put runners at second and third. Now, it’s way too tempting to put in a lefty to face a lefty and make that mid-inning pitching change, third mistake and two more runs come home. Thanks Doc. And while you’re at it, please bore me with another mid-inning pitching change. Floro mercifully ends the inning with a fly ball.
Roberts needs to stop putting himself and the team into these situations. Urias should have pitched the 6th, then this would have been a normal game. One inning each for Kelly and Baez then hand it off to Jansen. Instead, two innings each for Kelly and Baez and one batter each for Floro and Alexander. Alexander should not be limited to lefties only and maybe, just maybe, we should refrain from using Kelly for multiple innings until he finds his rhythm and has a couple of solid outings.
With a good manager and a normal spring training workload, we would be 6-0 right now. We can NOT go through April with false limits on the starting pitchers. If they look tired, pull them. If they’re cruising along, let them pitch. We are screwing up our pen by putting an unnecessary workload on them.
It was good to see Taylor go yard and have another hit. He gets on the board. He’s a good player and will have big moments all season. It was great seeing Verdugo leave the yard, but calm down Mark, fools day was yesterday and 30 homers is a big number. Hopefully he’ll ultimately be somewhere between Tony Gwynn and James Loney.
I hope we can get a little more length out of our starters especially when they have shutouts going in the near future. Let that sink in a little. Both losses came in games where the starting pitcher had shutouts going though 75 pitches. Geez.
I’m just a little concerned about facing left handed pitching right now. I guess we’ll know if that’s our Kryptonite again after the next two games.
Joc shouldn’t start against LHP regardless of how good he has done in 4 games. Its crazy to think people are even suggesting it. He can not hit LHP no matter how good you think he is doing, If Joc actually played full time his numbers would be garbage, so lucky for him he only plays against RHP. Verdugo on the other hand can hit LHP, he can put on a professional at bat against LHP, if Muncy doesn’t turn it around I can see Belly to 1st and Verdugo to Right in the very near future. I’ve been pleasantly surprised with Verdugo but I already knew he was going to prove the early nay sayers wrong, it is early but i like what I’m seeing from him, alot.