SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

To Trade or Not to Trade That is the Question

Whether tis nobler in the mind to suffer The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune of losing Trevor Bauer, Dustin May, and Clayton KershawOr to take Arms against a Sea of troubles by trading prospects for Max Scherzer or some other ilk Yes, old Billy has nothing on me. I m a poet but don t know it, yet my feet are Longfellows. OK, I ll stop right there. I wear size 15

By Mark Timmons3 min read56 comments

Whether ’tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune of losing Trevor Bauer, Dustin May, and Clayton Kershaw
Or to take Arms against a Sea of troubles by trading prospects for Max Scherzer or some other ilk…

Yes, old Billy has nothing on me. I’m a poet but don’t know it, yet my feet are Longfellows.

OK, I’ll stop right there. I wear size 15 shoes, but if not for my prehensile toes, they would be a Size 6. 😉

However, that is the question and some of it could be answered as soon as tonight if (as anticipated) JoJo Gray can step up and show out. It would seem to me that he should get the opportunity. JoJo has the tools to be a Top-of-the-Rotation Starter and sometimes guys like this take the league by storm and other times they get pounded. You never know.

Right about now, the Dodgers need a shot in the arm. Mookie was hot and then went down with a hip injury. It turns out it has been bothering him for a while. Corey Seager is due back at any time, but we can’t expect him to immediately hit like the World Series MVP. Cody Bellinger is struggling and experiencing some bad luck, but that’s what happens. Sometimes the baseball Gods just try you.

The Dodgers lost Dustin May, have had a plethora of injuries, will possibly lose Trevor Bauer for the season and Mookie Betts is a huge question. We don’t know what his hip injury is, but it seems serious. The fact is: Hip injuries do not fix themselves. I can’t speculate what is wrong, but I just know it ain’t good. I would guess he probably got an injection, which may help for a few weeks.

Corey Knebel is on his way back and it looks like early to mid-August for him (barring setbacks) and Clayton will be back then too, but are there just too many things to overcome? No, there is not, but do the Dodgers KNOW that? My favorite saying is this:

No Mountains Can be Moved… Until you KNOW Mountains Can be Moved

The only way for the Dodgers to overcome their injuries and overtake the Giants is to change their thinking. When you change your thinking, you change your destiny.

You may think I am going all metaphysical on you… and I am because it is true. There are times when the Dodger look lost and defeated. That was apparent last night. They were behind 3-0 in the first and then Muncy and Turner hit home runs in the bottom of the inning… and then they shut down! This is not on Andrew Friedman or Dave Roberts. This is on the Collective Soul of the team. Only they can fix it. It seems like they all hit or no one hits.

Gabe Kapler is a metaphysical guy and the Giants are confident. They are believers. They KNOW mountains can be moved. I don’t have problems with Dave Roberts lineups, use of the bullpen, and all of that. It’s all subjective. Everyone has an opinion and no one has all the data and info that Doc has. But Roberts is a guy who may not understand the metaphysical side of baseball and the impact that your thoughts… the teams’ Collective Thoughts have on the game. I would say that right about now, the Giants grasp that and embrace it, while the Dodgers do not! It is that simple… and yey so hard to achieve!

Dodger News & Notes

  • Steven Souza, Jr. is still playing at OKC.
  • Sheldon Noisy is playing a lot of shortstop for OKC. He is being groomed to take over for CT3, in case he leaves.
  • Tut Tut is still hitting .182 at OKC.
  • Matt Davidson has 14 HR at OKC.
  • Kaybear is biding his time, knowing that he is WAY too good to be at AAA.
  • Yasiel Sierra pitched his first “clean inning” last night at OKC (2 K’s).
  • OKC was the only Dodger Farm Team that played last night. If you want to know whether they won or lost… Look it up!
  • Quit sayng that Bellinger doen’t change his approach with two strikes. He did last night only to hit a liner to the LF’er. Pick a new mantra!
  • Victor Gonzalez looked awful last night. I think I give him a pass based upon his body of work. Let’s see his next outing.

Am I the Only One?

Discussion (56)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. BearJuly 21, 2021

    OKC trounced Reno 10-3. Ruiz, Tsutsugo, Neuse and Estevez all homered. Tsutsugo went 3-4 to raise his average to .207. The HR was his 6th. Ruiz had 3 hits adding a double and single to his line for the night. Neftali Feliz got the win, he pitched 1.2 innings with 1 walk and 3 K’s. Graterol had a clean inning striking out 2. Pazos gave up 1 run, and Quackenbush closed the game with a clean inning. Ramirez started and went 4.1 giving up 2 runs, walking 5 and striking out 3. He gave up only 2 hits.

  2. BearJuly 21, 2021

    Nice comeback and win. What is weird is the fact that I have seen all of Will Smith’s walk of HR’s. I was at Dodger Stadium when he hit his first, against the Phil’s in 2019. I was watching the Rockies series when he, Verdugo and Beaty all hit walk offs in a 3 game series, and then the one tonight. I think that even though he got tagged for 3 HR’s, I saw some good things out of Gray, and I think he will improve his next time out which would work out to Sunday against the Rockies. And the pen did their job, despite a few shaky moments and did not give up any more runs after Gray left. Taylor had a Mookie like game, and McKinstry made a huge defensive play when he was in RF. Beaty is no 3rd baseman, that is for sure, but with them carrying 14 pitchers, the bench is short. Early word is that Turner will most likely not play tomorrow, Muncy is day to day, and with his wife close to giving birth, I would not count on Max to be in there. So, guys like Reks, and Beaty, who for damn sure can hit, are going to have to step up, McKinstry too. Padres lost to Atlanta tonight to drop 4.5 back of LA. Dodgers have the same amount of wins as the Giants, and can be the first team to 60 with a win tomorrow. Congrats to the Bucks who came back from a 0-2 hole to beat Phoenix and win the NBA title. Chris Paul denied again.

  3. DavidJuly 21, 2021

    That’s the way, uh-huh, uh-huh, I like it! If adversity builds character, the Dodgers showed it tonight!

    What’s the big difference between this year and last year: injuries, plain and simple. We need to keep gutting out wins, making the best of a bad situation with our battered and bruised line-up (no, that is not a reference to TB!). Then, when we are finally healthy, we make a run for it, and hope that the Midgets finally regress to the mean. I predict that we will win the division, but it will be close. Unless the injury Gods are truly against us, and we lose major pieces for the rest of the season, but that is the one thing we can’t control.

    Regarding TB, I predict that we will never see him again in a Dodgers uniform. AF will get Max Scherzer for us, suspend TB for the rest of the season, then a long legal battle will ensue about his contract. I am agnostic about TB’s guilt or innocence, but his continued presence on the team would be a huge distraction.

  4. DukeJuly 21, 2021

    So Will Smith comes to the rescue…. Whew.

    But let’s review this game. Rough baptism for Josiah Gray…. Throwing Ks, giving up HRs.

    But how about that Alex Wood? Too bad he hit Turner and Muncy, but he’s having a fine year for the Giants, sort of like that guy Jake McGee.

    Where did the Giants find these guys? Why didn’t their last team pony up the $$?

    Well, as it turned out, some of that money would represent just a small fraction of what was spent to sign Bauer, who may or may not come back this season, and will forever be taunted as a choke artist.. As I’ve mentioned often, I was against signing Bauer, but not because I anticipated something like this. Doc and the players might pretend like Bauer’s troubles really don’t matter that much, but it sure can’t help team chemistry. If he’d suffered a season-ending injury like May, they’d say, well, that’s baseball. But this? They talk among themselves, they wish they’d never signed him and then they go home and their wives and girlfriends ask questions.

    Even the best case scenario for Bauer at this point is not a great one for the Dodgers.

    Anyway, that’s one reason AF isn’t just looking at rentals. I hope he is considering quality SPs under contract for more years, like Castillo and Berrios. Come to think, Scherzer supposedly wants a longer deal to waive his no-trade. What would it take? Can they swing it without including Ruiz or a top pitcher?

    And I still think another proven bat would help. One report suggest that the Giants are interested in Starling Castro. All-Star Adam Frazier is a Taylor type with less power–and he seems certain to be dealt. Right now, it seems we think Seager will return and again be Mr. October. No guarantee of that–and he, or another key player, could go down with injury.. Meanwhile, Belli struggles, and Lux, even when healthy, seems no better that the guys from OKC who showed they weren’t ready for prime time.

    Speaking of Lux, I hope he’s rooting for McKinstry…even if it means that he loses his starting job.

  5. peterjJuly 21, 2021

    Good night Mrs. Calabash wherever you are!!!

  6. nonicnamebumfanJuly 21, 2021

    Oh what a night,

    Late ninth inning and Smith walks it off

    What a moment what a night

  7. DodgerfanJuly 21, 2021

    Power outage at Dodger stadium, Will Smith turns off the light.

  8. CassidyJuly 21, 2021

    Season saving comeback!!!!!!!

  9. QuasimodoJuly 21, 2021

    Finally a 9th inning walkoff for Dodgers! Now the sprint starts here!

  10. EricJuly 21, 2021

    Smith bomb for the win.

  11. nonicnamebumfanJuly 21, 2021

    Beaty has been hitting the ball so hard lately he is so due. Everybody on your feet. We got it baby we got it baby we got it baby Smith walks it off how sweet it is

    I love LA

  12. SteviedJuly 21, 2021

    For all you dreamers, take Bauer off your list. Even if MLB clears him he will never pitch for the Dodgers again. Can you picture the reaction if he takes the mound at Dodger Stadium! The Dodgers, their fans and the city of Los Angeles would, rightfully so, never stand for it. The history of this wonderful franchise is too valuable to jeopardize it for a yo-yo like him.

    Go Dodgers!

  13. DodgerfanJuly 21, 2021

    The guy Taylor was talking to what’s his name

  14. nonicnamebumfanJuly 21, 2021

    What a crying shame. I feel sorry for this kid although I was looking forward to his major league debut, it really shouldn’t of been in such a high leverage situation. Against the team that’s leading us in the division and a game we really needed to win

  15. BulldogsandPenguinsJuly 21, 2021

    I think I’ve heard this song before. The opener will give up a run or two or three, then Gray will suck not being used to coming out of the bullpen.

    The script pretty much wrote itself.

    Remember that just a couple of weeks ago we swept a two game series against the Giants. Back away from the shotgun.

  16. EricJuly 21, 2021

    Josiah Gray doesn’t look so good.

  17. nonicnamebumfanJuly 21, 2021

    That’s OK kid, if you can pitch three or four more innings and not give up a run you did great. We’re all pulling for you

  18. TherealtenJuly 21, 2021

    Wood has never looked better!! The giant mediocre players hit homer homer homer.

  19. EricJuly 21, 2021

    Here we go again. Going to have to score a lot of runs to win with our current bullpen.

  20. TherealtenJuly 21, 2021

    This year is just very frustrating!! The injuries have killed us. I don’t think we can win the division with the current team as is.

    We need a starting rotation not a bullpen rotation. Current we have buhler, Urias, and price. U can’t really count Gonsolin as he is just an opener. Stretch him out blah blah. He has had plenty of time to stretch out. I really don’t think LA sends an injured pitcher out there but he has something wrong when your fastball drops 5 mph in the next inning. What frustrates me is no urgency!! Price could have been in the rotation some time back.AF response has been throw some more bullpen guys out there. Our bullpen is starting to show the stress.

    Our offense is basically turner and Muncy with a streaky pollock and smith hot so smith sits. The giants are going to just start walking Muncy or he will start going out of the zone. We have got to give Bellinger going to have a chance. I don’t think u can count on Betts with his injury and who knows if Seager will even come back. If he does will he have enough time to get comfortable? Btw the giant ss who replaced Crawford got a big hit. We need somebody to do that but instead reks ks 3 times. We just don’t have enough quality depth we need our starters mlp to perform.

    Our defense needs to play better but I don’t know if they can. Holding runners kills us but we seem helpless to do anything about it. Without our regulars and without our regulars performing we just are a good team but not a division champ. When and if kershaw comes back how many starts until he is ready? If Bauer comes back how long would that take? We need starters and productive starters.

  21. TMJuly 21, 2021

    It’s great to see a 0 on the scoreboard going into the bottom of the first. That has to be huge for the players too, not to be down this early in the game.

    Maybe the Vegas oddsmakers knew something I didn’t know.

  22. BoboJuly 21, 2021

    If there has ever been a day you haven’t done something stupid you aren’t a smart person.

    So far I’m brilliant.

  23. nonicnamebumfanJuly 21, 2021

    Anyone see the Lux reaction to the Muncy home run last night. They just showed it on the pregame show

    Man that kids got some facial expressions

  24. peterjJuly 21, 2021

    Wow!!! At the pool walking and come back to this crapola…

    Badger, MT, consider they’re like obscene phone callers…. No responses will kill em…

    P.S. Do you think Eric worked at Guantanamo??

    It’s Time for Dodger Baseball…

  25. TMJuly 21, 2021

    Could someone please explain to me how and why Vegas has the Dodgers as the favorites tonight? I mean come on….be real….just look at the pitching match ups to start with. This is always huge, I think we can all agree.

    Wood vs an assortment of unproven/questionable pitchers. This has to be considered a huge advantage for SF

    Hitters: look at our last 4 guys…..is there anyone who scares you….or you think scares their pitchers? Now I know the first 5 guys can go off and that may be all we need, but here is the rub for me….SF probably scores as many runs against our bullpen as they did last night against……our bullpen. We have to face Alex Wood, 8-3, and who knows our team pretty well. Advantage again has to be SF

    So again I ask….how are we the favorites? Home field maybe? Means nothing in this rivalry, in my opinion. Doc is the better manager? I can’t imagine anyone giving an “amen” to that one either. So why?

    In conclusion: my “gut” is telling me tomorrow morning when I wake up to check on the score, I may not be smiling. I hope my gut is wrong, but most of the time my gut (which is connected to my brain) is spot on! Nevertheless….GO LA….JUST DO IT AND SHOCK THE WORLD….or at least my gut!

  26. BulldogsandPenguinsJuly 21, 2021

    Wow, I’m still laughing at “Smart people do stupid things every day.” I mean, isn’t that exactly the opposite of what smart people do?

  27. Mark TimmonsJuly 21, 2021

    You guys kill me. Mookie said he was fine and would be back today. So Mookie is a liar too. Everyone is a liar. You are smart and Doc is dumb! Feel better?

    You should be MLB managers.

  28. EricJuly 20, 2021

    I knew Doc was lying yesterday when he said Mookie Betts would start today. Turns out Betts is not starting today. Why no Smith today?

    Taylor

    Muncy

    Turner

    Pujols

    Pollock

    Bellinger

    Barnes

    McKinstry

    Nunez

  29. BadgerJuly 20, 2021

    This team has a completely different presence without Seager and Bellinger. Even without them they are still favored to win. Even with Bauer in question, Kershaw on his yearly IL rehab and Mookie questionable, Lux, and… Reks, we are still favored to beat them tonight and win the Division in two months. Most of the so called experts, and the money, still likes the Dodgers. So do I.

  30. Mark TimmonsJuly 20, 2021

    DODGERS SELECT RHP JOSIAH GRAY

    LOS ANGELES – The Los Angeles Dodgers selected the contract of right-handed pitcher Josiah Gray and placed left-handed pitcher Scott Alexander on the injured list with left shoulder inflammation. In order to make room on the 40-man roster, the Dodgers designated infielder Andy Burns for assignment.

    Gray, 23, was 1-1 with a 2.87 ERA (5 ER/15.2 IP) and 22 strikeouts in four games (three starts) for Triple-A Oklahoma City. In his first full season in the Dodgers organization, he was named the 2019 Branch Rickey Minor League Pitcher of the Year after going a combined 11-2 with a 2.28 ERA (33 ER/130.0 IP) with 147 strikeouts in 26 games (25 starts) between Low-A Great Lakes, High-A Rancho Cucamonga and Double-A Tulsa. In his minor league career, he is 14-5 with a 2.41 ERA in 42 games (40 starts). He was originally acquired via trade with infielder Jeter Downs from the Cincinnati Reds on December 21, 2018.

    Alexander, 32, heads to the injured list for the second time this season. He appeared in the game last night, tossing 0.1 innings and allowing two hits. In 18 games this season, he is 0-2 with a 2.93 ERA (5 ER/15.1 IP) and eight strikeouts. He has been in the Major Leagues for parts of seven seasons with the Kansas City (2015-17) and Los Angeles (2018-21) and is a combined 12-9 with a 3.16 ERA (72 ER/205.0 IP) and 160 strikeouts in 211 games. The Northern California native was originally acquired by the Dodgers in a three-team trade with Kansas City Royals and Chicago White Sox on January 4, 2018.

  31. Mark TimmonsJuly 20, 2021

    Couple of points to make:

    1. In David Prices’ first two outings of the year, he had a 12.00+ ERA. Since then it has been around 2.00. Cut the guy some slack as he builds up his arm strength.

    2. Tony Gonsolin is HORRID, TERRIBLE, AWFUL, BAD, and DOWNRIGHT CRAPPY… and BTW has a 2.83 ERA.

    FTI, you people have taken leave of your senses.

  32. MushersPopJuly 20, 2021

    So who gets dfa for Gray? I’m guessing Raley.

  33. peterjJuly 20, 2021

    Kudos Bear on Seager!!! Some it seems have never played the game…

    Good day for reading… Puig??? I gave up on his ass when he was nailed speeding in Fla. with his Mom in the back seat… All the God given talent in the world and the IQ of a fence post…

    Go get em tonight…

  34. hbdodger48July 20, 2021

    I am really getting tired of the disappearing act of Corey Seager. Sorry but it does not take 10 weeks to heal a fractured pinkie. What is he waiting for? He has already missed 43% of the regular season games since 2018. He is dreaming if he thinks he is going to get Lindor kind of money. I really don’t see the Dodgers signing him to a long term contract even though he was our key offensive player in the playoffs last year. I really like Corey but his below average defense along with being injury prone tells me we need to move on and find another SS.

  35. porpoiseboyJuly 20, 2021

    I sure hope mad Max’s wife holds out until either rockies weekend or the weekend after with AZ. Just NOT for either of the midgets series.

    COME ON MRS MUNCY, we are rooting for you!

  36. BearJuly 20, 2021

    Hard to believe that at 30 years old, with only 7 years of MLB time, Puig is already out of the league and playing in Mexico. What a waste of talent. I agree that Burns will most likely be the player moved off of the 40 man so Gray can be activated. Burns is on the 7 day IL at OKC anyway.

  37. BearJuly 20, 2021

    Great subject today Mark. And they will trade. The question remains, who for who? I hear and see a lot of names bandied around. I do not know if AF is targeting a big ticket pitcher, I would think he is leaning more towards someone like Gibson than Berrios. Berrios will cost a lot. Maybe 2 of your top 10 prospects. Scherzer want’s at least a 2 year extension BEFORE he will waive his no trade clause. If I were chasing a bat, I would definitely kick the tires on Haniger of the Mariners. He could definitely be a difference maker, and easily help the offense a lot. Make no mistake, the Giants are for real. And those old guys and fringe players they have believe they are the best and they are playing like it. And they have injury issues too, so they are getting great contributions from the guys replacing the regulars. Belt, Crawford, Longoria and LaStella are all on the IL. The Dodger AAA players who have been called up this year have not performed nearly as well as the Giants subs have. Raley and Reks were both raking at OKC, well over .300. Ravelo was too but they let him leave and sign with a Japanese team. They brought in Tsutsugo because they thought they could fix his swing and make him back into the player he was in Japan, nope. And he has just now started to show a pulse at OKC. Still hitting under the Mendoza line. AF did not load the roster at OKC with a lot of former MLB starters like he did a few times before. The only guy down there with much experience is Kickham. Of their top prospects, the one I promote tomorrow is Ruiz. I do not trade him, I trade Austin Barnes as a throw in for the best starter we can get. Ruiz’s bat is definitely an upgrade from Barnes. I like Austin, he plays hard, but he is just a weak link in the order, and without a DH, he pretty much makes the last two spots in the order automatic outs. I have long railed against Roberts for his in game strategies, and I think he made a blunder last night. Bickford was pitching well, and Roberts pulled him after a hit with one out and brought in Gonzalez simply because a lefty was coming up. Dave did it because Bickford’s splits against lefty’s are not that good. But it totally backfired because everything Gonzalez threw up there was hittable. Bickford has more K’s than innings pitched. I would have let him try to finish the inning. Gonzalez is not the same pitcher this season as last. And the stats reflect that. He pounded the strike zone last season, and this season he is not doing that. He will probably get better, but he was just off of the IL, and looked like it. His only action was against low A hitters a couple days before. Vesia comes in and is lights out. Dave needs to develop some new strategies. Do I have all the answers? No, I am not privy to the real Dr.s report on Mookie’s hip, Seager’s pinky, Belli’s shoulder and leg. But Bellinger is one of the best defensive players in the league, and I give him a lot of credit that his defense has not suffered because he is in a slump. Another thing that bugs me is all the shifting they do. Back in the day, late in the game, they used to play what was called no doubles defense. Which meant that the 3rd baseman and the left fielder were pretty much hugging the line with a righty at bat. That would have changed the whole scenario when Estrada hit his double down the line in the 7th. Had Turner been playing deep and on the line, he probably would have got that ball and had a double play. But he was in and off the line, so he had no shot. Pollock was playing way over in left center field and had no way to cut the ball off, so it rattled around in the corner and two runs scored. Game definitely over with the way the offense was performing at that point. Now they all pull out their little cards and look where the data tells them to play, and damn the idea that someone might just hit it in a different direction. Oh yeah, Gonsolin needs to learn how to bunt, or at least hit the ball the other way. They all need to learn not to swing at pitches a snake could not hit.

  38. Mark TimmonsJuly 20, 2021

    1. I VIOLENTLY disagree that Gonsolin is hurt. There is no way they would let him pitch if he was. That’s an uninformed erroneous opinion. The Dodgers spend too much time and money on these guys to let them pitch when they are injured… unless he is injured and telling no one. More likely, he is just building up like pitchers do in the Spring. It takes a month or longer. The opinion is not rooted in fact.

    2. You have no clue if Pollock had an issue or asked out or if it was a planned day off. Your opinion is based on what you saw, but not necessarily the facts.

    3. That is your “GO TO” after every game the Dodgers lose. It’s getting old and it’s another opinion.

    4. OK, but I will not sell the farm.

    5. It would be great to do that, but there is still a lot of time.

    Sometimes people have to struggle in order to succeed. Ponder that!

  39. EricJuly 20, 2021

    Thoughts:

    1) It’s obvious to me that Gonsolin is still injured.

    2) Boneheaded Doc sits Pollock for Reks IN AN EXTREMELY IMPORTANT GAME. Don’t tell me this kinda thing hasn’t happened before.

    3) Our bullpen is just not good enough to win a World Series.

    4) Trades are needed for both starting pitching and bullpen help if you want to try to win the World Series.

    5) The Dodgers need to win all 3 remaining with the Giants or it will be a failure to seize the moment.

  40. Andrew Vincent ForteJuly 20, 2021

    The Dodgers have agreed to a deal with left-hander Maddux Bruns, their top pick (29th overall) in the 2021 MLB Draft, a source told MLB Pipeline’s Jonathan Mayo on Tuesday. The club has not confirmed the deal, which is for $2.2 million, according to Mayo. The slot value for the pick was $2,424,600.

    Bruns, a 6-foot-2, 205-pound southpaw from UMS-Wright Preparatory School in Alabama, went 7-0 with a 0.86 ERA as a senior, allowing just 13 hits and six earned runs over 49 innings of work. Bruns has a four-seam fastball that stands out, topping out at 98 mph last season, a significant jump from the low-90s the prior year.

    Bruns, who was named after Hall of Fame pitcher Greg Maddux and ranked the No. 49 Draft prospect by Pipeline, was a Mississippi State recruit.

  41. Cynical Dodger FanJuly 20, 2021

    Reading Timmons’ columns reminds me of that old saying: “Put wishes in one hand, crap in the other. See which fills up faster.”

    Sure, I WISH Bellinger would start hitting again. I WISH Bauer had never met that girl. I WISH Seager would heal faster. I WISH Mookie was healthy. I WISH the Dodgers’ offensive depth was of a higher quality than has been apparent. I WISH the Giants were not good this year. I WISH Dave Roberts would abandon the LR matchup script once in a while and manage by what he sees. I wish hot hitters would not be on the bench for critical games.

    Wishes are fun but they’re not reality.

  42. Singing The BlueJuly 20, 2021

    Random thoughts:

    1) Totally agree with dRick and others that Catman is hurt. Some doctor must have told them it won’t get any worse if he pitches so that’s what they’re doing. Wouldn’t be surprised to see surgery after the season.

    2) Speaking of surgery, I think Mookie has the same problem that Posey had in 2018. That led to hip surgery and he wasn’t the same until this year. I definitely expect to see Mookie go under the knife this winter. Hopefully he’ll be back in time for next season but he may not be the same again for a couple years if he follows the Posey recovery timeline. He’s younger and also hasn’t had the physical stress of being a catcher, so that should help.

    3) I expect to see AF trade for a controllable outfielder this month since Mookie can’t be counted on from day to day. This isn’t going to get better any time soon. I see someone like Bryan Reynolds, Cedric Mullins or Lourdes Gurriel as possibilities although a couple of those guys would come at a very high cost, prospect wise. If I’m correct about Mookie’s situation and with Pollock having one year left here, coupled with a real lack of good outfield prospects in the system, I think this is the way to solve that problem.

    4) Andrew needs to pick up at least one strong starter. The Reds are beginning to look like they might be sellers so maybe he could get them to part with one of Castillo, Mahle or Miley, any of whom would be stronger alternatives than what we have now. Other names that everyone is mentioning include Scherzer and Berrios and possibly Kyle Hendricks. I don’t know if it will be a rental or someone with some years of control left but I expect he’ll come up with someone. The only problem is that Preller and Farhan will be in the same marketplace, Preller in particular.

  43. dodgerrickJuly 20, 2021

    Gonsolin pitches like a guy with a sore shoulder. Last year he averaged 95.1 MPH with the fastball topping out at 98. (Per MLB Savant.) This year he’s throwing at 92 – 93. He’s also lost his release point and is leaving it up. That’s what you do with a sore shoulder. I’m surprised that the Dodgers are letting him pitch.

    They got only 4 hits last night after knocking the Giants’ best starter out after 3 innings. That’s really horrible. Looking at the lineup, Turner and Muncy did damage. Nothing else happening. Pollock came in late and got a hit. He’s the hottest hitter in the league in July and in a game where Mookie was unavailable, they sit him for Zack Reks?

    Gonzalez didn’t have anything last night, but Roberts left him out there to take his lumps. Every ball was hard hit. He doesn’t look ready either. Giving up 4 runs in the 7th isn’t going to win many games.

  44. BulldogsandPenguinsJuly 20, 2021

    Yes, it’s a perfectly reasonable solution to trade away Lux. After all why stick with a young blue chip prospect that’s probably your best defensive shortstop when both of your other Major Leaguers who can play shortstop are free agents after the season?

    Same thing with Belli. Ignore the injuries, ignore the MVP season. Ignore the Gold Glove defense in CF. Just trade him.

    I’m actually optimistic that Doc mentioned before the game that Belli should concentrate on using the field and being a hitter first and the slug will follow. He made some baby steps last night hitting the ball the other way and not striking out against one of the top pitchers in the league who also piles up strikeouts.

    Everyone that’s piling on Belli was piling on Pollock not long ago.

    The bottom of the order was crap last night. I saw that as soon as the lineup came out. You don’t think we could have scored another run or two if Pujols and Pollock were in there? Unfortunately Beaty pulled two screamers just foul and hit a rocket the other way but within reach of the third baseman. V-Gone sharted himself and there’s the game. Is that a call or reason for drastic changes?

    Management is managing this team for the long haul, like it or not. I don’t like that they decided to give Kershaw a vacation. I don’t like that they are having Brusdar working on off-speed pitches in the minors. I don’t like how they waited so long with Cody and Corey. But, it is what it is and they have a pretty good track record on their side.

    Make a trade to add, not subtract from this team. I will say this again, we have just about the best offense in the league and have only used our best lineup once.

    Tonight’s lineup will feature Pujols at first, Muncy at second and CT3 at SS against lefty Alex Wood. I would assume that Barnes will be behind the plate since he’s less horrible against lefties.

    They’re gonna do that opener Bullcrap and Gray will make his debut during a grudge match. I hate this brand of baseball with all the shifts, openers and bullpen games. In retrospect, management should have committed to Price in the rotation sooner and probably have given Gonsolin a little more time to bake in the minors. The bullpen is being ridden hard right now and it shows.

  45. Mark TimmonsJuly 20, 2021

    Who will the Dodgers drop off the 40-Man Roster to clear a spot for Gray?

    My guess is Andy Burns.

  46. TMJuly 20, 2021

    Anyone who thought we would win last night after hearing the news that Mookie would be out is a huge optimist, and guys like me (realist) probably frustrate you. I did tell my wife though before the game started, “if our pitcher can get by the first inning with no runs, we may have a chance…..”.

    Well, he didn’t…….. but there was good news, I was able to catch up on my sleep.

    Should we trade? Lol. Even though I haven’t been here long, I’m sure you know what I think. Yes, yes, yes…..BELLINGER (2.5 seasons and counting) AND LUX (mentally fragile) ….in order to get more pitching and maybe an intriguing OF prospect.

  47. toycannon23July 20, 2021

    GM Guys – I agree with y’all getting frustrated with Belli . Think need maybe sit him down for few games next to Albert clear his head, definitely pressing. Conversely, find it ironic that Yelich hasnt been same hitter either since him and Belli battled for MVP 2 years ago. Have no doubt we get everybody back healthy (HOPEFULLY keep them healthy) that Belli will click !! Have great day !

  48. BadgerJuly 20, 2021

    Mookie, Seager, Turner, and Muncy. Everyone else hits 8th.

  49. TherealtenJuly 20, 2021

    Cody does not hit the ball to lf. He seems to at least try to keep from striking out with 2 strikes by lunging off balance to make contact. Since his slump he often goes out of the zone chasing especially with 2 strikes. The opposing pitchers just throw it right down the middle and he hasn’t been able to catch up. I continue to think he will produce. If not now in the future. When he bats I always think this could be the at bat whereas when Taylor bats and gets behind in the count u know it is a strikeout. After Muncy and turner I am about as confident in bellinger as the rest. Pollock is hot but it won’t last, smith is overall good but I am always aware of the dp ball and warning track power to rf. Then there is Betts. He has shown what he is capable of but his injuries have stopped him in the first half. Many as well as me think we would not have won the ws without him. Well we r without him. The rest aren’t worth talking about. Seager is a game changer if he don’t get a hang nail. Dodger players seem to spend a lifetime on the il. Seems unexplainable that Seager would b out this long.

  50. porpoiseboyJuly 20, 2021

    Well it was 11pm at the end of the 6th last night, so I went to bed. Apparently the best decision I have made yet this week.

  51. sbuffaloJuly 20, 2021

    Well, looking back at last night’s game and only that game, with the Dodgers trailing, 3-2 in the bottom of the first, runners on first and second, one out, Matt Beaty hits a shot right at the third baseman. Game over.

    Obviously, Tony Gonsolin pitched poorly. Why didn’t AJ Pollock start? Zak Reks? Struck out all three times. Looks lost. Why is he even in the line-up? Especially in an important game.

    As to Keibert Ruiz. Will the Dodgers keep him or package him in a trade for pitching? Some thinking he will be moved at the trade deadline. But then maybe the Dodgers should keep him for the bat, for the future, can’t get enough players who can actually hit, right? They can probably pull off a trade or two or three using only players in the system. Can they pick up a difference maker or two at the trade deadline next week?

    The Giants will no doubt make a move or two. Pressure on. This is Friedman vs. Zaidi.

    I appreciate Mark pointing out that Gabe Kapler is a metaphysical guy. I thought he was just weird. But he has done a good job so far getting the most out of a bunch old guys, the best days behind them. Hey and Farhan hit the jackpot with a couple of pitchers.

  52. tedraymondJuly 20, 2021

    I look at the Giants lineup and can’t believe they are a first place team. How do the Giants lead the NL in HR’s? Other than Posey they have no stars to speak of. And, Posey is load managed to keep him productive. A bunch of no name pitchers as starters and in the BP. With the Dodgers it’s one injury after another. Why does it take Bellinger and Seager so long to recover from seemingly minor injuries? It is a miracle that we have as good a record as we do. I’m not very optimistic for the remaining of the season for things to change on the injury front. And then throw in the Bauer debacle to complete the unbelievable. It’s seems one step forward and two steps back on the injury front. Let’s hope that changes soon.

    It’s great to have your knowledge and comments back philjones!

    It was nice to see Bellinger go to left field last night, but come on Mark, that doesn’t prove that he can make adjustments with two strikes. If he does it on a consistent basis I’ll buy in. Lately, he has had plenty of opportunities to make adjustments with two strikes. I mean even Roberts expectations are for him to just hit it forward (not strike out). How pathetic that those are the expectations for the MVP from two years ago? You would think that at this point he would at least try to lay down a bunt or just make contact like he did last night in his final AB. He drove in a couple of runs the other day with a feeble swing and a dunker to CF. I was ecstatic and thought maybe this is the start of something to build on. Nope. Remaining AB’s no real attempt for contact while swinging for the fences. He needs some time on the bench or at least get dropped to the 7-8th spot in the lineup.

  53. BadgerJuly 20, 2021

    It’s my opinion that Gonsolin is a relief pitcher.

    To trade or not to trade.

    You know where I stand.

    Friedman is no doubt looking around. We need pitching. But we need our first string on the field every night to best the better teams. Like it or not, the better teams are in our Division.

    When we get the varsity back on the field, add pitching, we are good enough to win 3 of 5. We will remain a blind squirrel operation because that’s just who are, so there will be olive swallowing games on occasion, please excuse the mixed metaphors, but I think the odds makers are right. We are 70% favorites for a reason. 70% favorites will win 60% of their games. And that should get us the Division.

  54. norcaldodgerfanJuly 20, 2021

    .164 BA, .283 OBP, .276 SLG—–Bellinger

    Going on ten weeks for a non-surgical bone fracture–Seager

    Pennant drive and the team starts Reks and Beaty…need I say more

    Vesia looked unhittable in Denver and it appears he has found his stuff, but Doc brings in V-Gon who just came off the IL—–bonehead move!

    Bickford’s arm is going to fall off if he keeps being used at this rate.

    Posey comes off the IL with no re-hab games and gets a two-run HR in the first inning while we wait for Seager to get right.

    Giants BP was lights out last night….is their BP better than ours?

    Belli went oppo on a line drive out to LF and some view it as progress while I see the numbers that look absolutely putrid and embarrassing.

  55. BulldogsandPenguinsJuly 20, 2021

    It was bad news right from the start when a hot Mookie was scratched from the lineup. Maybe the computer said the team would be better off stacking lefties at the bottom of the lineup since Gausman’s splits say so. Maybe Pollock is incapable of playing seven games in a row, so they might as well give him a rest now.

    With 67 games remaining there’s plenty of time to make up a couple of games and to get players healthy for a deep run. No need to put extra urgency on a July game just because they’re playing the team they’ve been looking up to in the standing for most of the season. It’s more important to give regulars some vacation time and keep the bench “relevant”.

    I don’t know, sometimes you have to lose a battle to win the war. Perhaps the thought was that the first game of the series would be a sacrificial lamb knowing that Gausman would be a tough hill to climb anyways. It could be that the computer upstairs knows the Giants will eventually fold. Or, AF is trying to trick the Giants into thinking they’re contenders so they don’t sell at the break and reload their farm system.

    I was lucky enough to fall asleep right before V-Gone gave it up like a Bauer Instagram follower. On the bright side, Gonsolin is built up to 80 pitches. He should be good for 4 innings the next time out. Maybe Jo-jo will have a Fernando type start to his career tonight and change the trajectory for the series.

    It’s obviously not optimal to have to play our rivals with Kershaw, Seager, Mookie, Knebel, Nelson and Lux on the shelf and especially against of the league’s best pitchers to open the series and to play it with a short bench. Sometimes timing is everything. I’m not going to get hysterical and jump ship just because a bucket of water has settled in the hull. I remain confident that leaks will be patched and ship will continue forward until we reach our destination.

    So much for starting the second half on a hot streak. It all looked pretty rosey just a couple of days ago after drubbing the Rockies those first two games. Adversity builds character I guess. What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, I’ve been told.

  56. TherealtenJuly 20, 2021

    The Dodgers are in a world of hurt! They cannot win throwing out milb players in a Mlb game. I realize righty lefty matchup but throwing reks out there in this huge game. Well how did that work out. Struck out 3 times in a row before I went to bed. He replaced the Dodgers hottest hitter in pollock huh true. Pollock in a streak with first place on the line and he sits. As usual no urgency. Just a little contact could have changed the whole game. At least doc could have batted him 8th.

    Gonsolin has been terrible and could not make the Giants rotation. He is not able to get it done. With Betts, seager, out the replacements are just not good enough. Beaty, reks , had no business being in that game. I don’t blame doc he has to play who he has. AF can’t have a 200 million payroll. We have who we have and they are not good enough. Supposedly we r frantically looking for sp sorry too little too late. We can’t give up but this current team is good but not good enough.

More from Dodger Talk

Nothing Wrong With Back of the Rotation SP for LAD

I said it when Roki Sasaki was struggling…If not Roki, who? He finally started to pitch with more confidence and he put together a string of positive starts. Yes, there were those who forgot about his previous four excellent starts and instead focused on his CWS start. He is a…

By Jeff Dominique · June 16, 202670

Who Bats Where?

A good percentage of comments on this blog relate to “who bats where” in the batting order. “Shohei should bat cleanup.” “ Freddie should be the number three hitter.” “No, Freddie should hit second.” “Max Muncy should hit cleanup.” “Mookie should hit 9th.” … and on and on… Where…

By Mark Timmons · June 15, 2026104

Happy, Hopeful, Blessed, and Thankful

I grew up in Ohio and lived there until 1976, when I was 23 years old. I have been in Indiana for 50 years, so I consider myself a Hoosier. Now, I actually live 45 minutes from Bloomington, where the IU Hoosiers play. However, since I was nine years old, I have been a Dodger…

By Mark Timmons · June 14, 2026123

Are You True Blue?

What do I mean by true blue? Well, over the years I have seen my share of bandwagon and fair-weather fans. True blue fans stick with the team no matter what. Their allegiance to the team never waivers. Not when a favorite is traded or lost to free agency, not when the team…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · June 13, 202693