SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Much Too Early Prediction Monday

Let’s assume that the Dodgers make no more changes to their roster. That’s not likely, but for the purposes of this exercise, we’ll make it so. These are my predictions for how the players presently on the 40 man roster will perform next year: Pitchers: W L ERA IP H R BB SO SV WHIP Scott Alexander 2 3 4.12 53 48 17 26 48 1 1.235 Pedro Baez

By Mark Timmons4 min readJump to 98 comments

Let’s assume that the Dodgers make no more changes to their roster.   That’s not likely, but for the purposes of this exercise, we’ll make it so.  These are my predictions for how the players presently on the 40 man roster will perform next year: 

Pitchers:                      W        L          ERA    IP     H      R       BB      SO   SV   WHIP 

Scott Alexander            2           3       4.12       53    48     17      26       48     1      1.235

Pedro Baez                    6           3       2.90       73    54     24      25       75     1      0.980

Walker Buehler          17           6       2.87     212  176     84      42     226     0      1.028

JT Chargois                              Spends the year in the minors

Caleb Ferguson             6           3       2.97       64    54     19      31       78     0      1.320

Dylan Floro                              Spends the year in the minors

Tony Gonsolin              7           4       3.37       89    71     30      21       92     2      1.034

Victor Gonzalez            1           2       4.35       23    24     10      10       23     0      1.478

Kenley Jansen   4           1       3.09       71    54     22      15       87    33     0.972

Joe Kelly                       3           5       4.06       64    48     26      26       65     0      1.156

Clayton Kershaw        14           7       3.17     189  153     60      46     194     0      1.052

Adam Kolarek   1           1       2.12       33    22       7       7        29     0      0.879

Kenta Maeda              10           9       4.09     164  143     67      49     174     0      1.171

Dustin May                 10           5       3.39     153  141     52      29     169     0      1.111

Casey Sadler                             Spends the year in the minors

Dennis Santana                         Spends the year in the minors

Josh Sborz                                                        Spends the year in the minors

Ross Stripling               9           5         3.33    123  116    41      31     128     0      1.195

Blake Treinen                           0           2         2.46      61    44    15      15       87   10      0.967

Julio Urias                              11           7         3.73    177  153    66      38     183     0      1.079

Mitchell White                         Spends the year in the minors

Catchers:                                                         AB       R    H   2B  3B   HR   RBI   SB   SO    BA    OPS    

Austin Barnes                         184     30   41  13     1    8      34       3    47   .223    .653

Keibert Ruiz                           Spends the year in the minors

Will Smith                              382     68   91  15     2   18     59       4    71  .254    .811

Infielders:

Matt Beaty                              321      52   89   22    0    15    80       1    42   .277    .822

Enrique Hernandez                 450      60 106   21    2    18    66       8  102   .236    .725           

Gavin Lux                               249      51   77   18    3    11    61       5    49   .309    .850           

Zach McKinstry                        54      13   15     6    0     4     20       1    20   .278    .720           

Max Muncy                            590    103 165   32    0    31   101       2  110   .279    .910

Edwin Rios                             125      21   36   11    0    12    48       0    56   .288    .862           

Corey Seager                          601      98 191   50    2    24    96       3  112   .318    .915

Justin Turner                           570      86 167   33    0    28     98       0    93   .292    .836

Tyler White                            Spends the year in the minors

Outfielders:

Cody Bellinger                       630    124 198 40    13  43    122     23   112   .315  1.063

Kyle Garlick                             62      17   18    9      0    8     17       0     26   .290    .798

Joc Pederson                           511      88 129 26      1  31     80       3   118   .252    .987

DJ Peters                                   50      10   14    3      0    5     14       0     24   .288    .828

A.J. Pollock                            426      61 121 19      0  22      78       0   121   .284    .802

Chris Taylor                            430      59 115 21      2  17      62       3   127   .267    .821

Alex Verdugo                         481      66 145 28      3  18     71       3   119   .299    .821

Some Minor League Players who may contribute or are September call-ups:

W        L          ERA    IP     H      R       BB      SO   SV   WHIP

Josiah Gray                             0          0        3.33       12      8       4        3       14     0      0.917

Marshall Kasowski                 0          0        1.43         7      4       1        3       10     0      1.000

Casey Crosby                          0          1        3.89       18    10       7      14       22     0      1.333

AB       R    H   2B  3B   HR   RBI   SB   SO    BA    OPS

Jeter Downs                            12        3     4      1     0     1       5        0     5   .333    .700

Because of the constraints of time, I didn’t accurately determine what the batting average and OPS would be for the position players.  I did have to get some work done this weekend. 

I do not think there’s a snowball’s chance on a So. California summer’s day, that the 40 man roster will not change between now and the beginning of Spring Training.   It will be different.  How different, I have no idea.  

Now it’s your turn.   Let’s take a break from bashing the front office and speculating as to whom the Dodgers will trade for, etc, and have a Monday fun day.  Take some risks with your predictions, as “the points don’t matter and every prediction is made up.”  Despite that, there will be a prize of some sort for those who’s predictions most often come the closest to what actually happens.   There will also be a very special prize for that person who remembers at the end of next season that we did this today.   

One last thing: shortly after reading that Kluber was traded to the Rangers, I was listening to a Traffic album on my iMusic and, with apologies to Jim Capaldi and Stevie Winwood, I revised the “Dear Mr. Fantasy” lyrics as follows: 

Dear Mr. Friedman make us a trade

Something to make us all happy

Do anything, take us out of this gloom

Trade for Lindor, buy a starter, but make it snappy

You are the one who can make us all laugh

But doing nothing will bring the tears and jeers

Please don’t say you will, if you don’t care to spend 

Cause we have been patient for all these years

Discussion (98)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. BoboDecember 16, 2019

    Rudy, ha ha, well done, very funny.

  2. DodgerHorseDecember 16, 2019

    The Dodgers are a Ferrari, with Cole it was sought to give it more power, it was not achieved but they are still a Ferrari.

  3. DodgerHorseDecember 16, 2019

    The Dodgers need a pitcher like Clevinger right now, that would make a hypothetical October rotation of:

    1 Buehler

    2 Clevinger

    3 Urias

    4 May / Kershaw

    The Dodgers could have Lindor, Betts, Trout together on the team but if Kershaw starts two games in the world series, I’m sorry to tell you that we’re not going to win, Kershaw and Ryu himself can’t stop a strong American league offense, no It reaches them, so another pitcher No.1 or No.2 would give kershaw only one game.

    Lindor will always be welcome but pitchers are more urgent.

  4. DodgerHorseDecember 16, 2019

    The Dodgers need a pitcher like Clevinger right now, that would make a hypothetical October rotation of: 1 Buehler

    2 Clevinger

    3 Urias

    4 May / Kershaw

    The Dodgers could have Lindor, Betts, Trout together on the team but if Kershaw starts two games in the world series, I’m sorry to tell you that we’re not going to win, Kershaw and Ryu himself can’t stop a strong American league offense, no It reaches them, so another pitcher No.1 or No.2 would give kershaw only one game.

    Lindor will always be welcome but pitchers are more urgent.

  5. James moyaDecember 16, 2019

    Fuckin stan kasten aka smithers from the simpsons needs to make a move

  6. CassidyDecember 16, 2019

    2d now make your playoff predictions. That’s what really matters!

  7. peterjDecember 17, 2019

    DodgerRick:

    With Homeboy Moya’s takes it’s all about the IQ!!!

  8. peterjDecember 17, 2019

    Truth be said, I don’t want to lose Ruiz, but can anyone give me an idea what the future holds for Diego Cartaya??? Saw him in a couple games in the AZL and I liked the kid.. Comfortable behind the dish with good footwork…

  9. Mark TimmonsDecember 17, 2019

    If Cartaya is what he is projected to be then I could see trading Ruiz, but I can’t make that determination until he get to GL. I think he should be pushed.

  10. Mark TimmonsDecember 17, 2019

    There are rumblings that Clevinger has some serious back/shoulder issue.

    Also, it’s possible that Lux, Ruiz and Gonsolin could be better than Lindor and Clevinger.

    I was studying some video in the DR and Lux has came so far, but I don’t think he even close to where he will be…. maybe THIS year.

  11. norcaldodgerfanDecember 17, 2019

    Wade Miley, Alex Wood, Julio Tehran, Andrew Cashner, Homer Baily, Jason Vargas, Gio Gonzales, Jhoulys Chacin and many others pitchers are still available. Some of these look like a typical FA signing/reclamation project we’ve far too often become accustomed with.

    If the FO is indeed going to improve the SP it will have to by way of a trade, otherwise take a hard pass on any of the available FA starting pitchers still available sans Ryu.

  12. rudybyrdDecember 17, 2019

    Cross Wade Miley off the list (Reds)

  13. SoCalBumDecember 17, 2019

    Career stats (Baseball Reference) against teams with .500+ winning records.

    Clevinger: .252 / .344 / .422 / .766 tOPS+ 1.33

    Maeda: .237 / .312 / .416 / .727. tOPS+ 116

    Ryu: .245 / .293 / .380 / .681 tOPS+ 1.02

    Buehler: .197 / .262 / .333 / .596. tOPS+ 94

    Kershaw: .119 / .175 / .131 / .306. tOPS+ 58

    Obviously not facing the same opponents. Draw your own conclusions. For me, to trade May I want a better pitcher against .500+ teams than Clevinger.

  14. DodgerBlueMomDecember 17, 2019

    I enjoy reading Jayne Cobb’s comments especially about the minor league experiences. Good stuff. Maybe she could write a column here. You think Mark?

  15. Mark TimmonsDecember 17, 2019

    Scouts still rave about Julio Urias’ stuff, but Dustin May is very close and Tony Gonsolin is also there.

    As you know, I was not happy with the drafting of Lux and Kendall. Kendal has all the “WOW Tools” but he is still a big disappointment. All Lux did was what I tell employees I hire:

    1. Show Up;

    2. Step Up;

    3. Shut Up!

    As I mentioned, I was watching video of his swing and you can see him get better, day-by-day. This kid just keeps evolving. I have warmed up to him to the point of where he is untouchable. Lindor benefits immensely by playing at the Jake. He hits .310 at home (.374 OB%) and .266 on the road (.320 OB%). To put it another way, his OPS at home is .901 (superstar), but on the rod it is .781 (Journeyman).

    I don’t not get the fascination with him, and neither does AF. I guarantee it! He will never be a Dodger unless Cleveland just rolls over.

    In 2019, Lindor hit .284 with a .335 OB% and had a ,854 OPS. He did hit 32 HR, but he would have had less if he played in Chavez Ravine.

    Lux could put up similar numbers in his rookie year.

    Lux could be ROY and May could be RPOY.

    Shadddduuupppp with all this nonsense, already!

    I think DodgerRick has it all figured out. I think he is finally thinking what I am… but I am thinking what I am now because of what he said!

  16. HawkeyedodgerDecember 17, 2019

    I trust AF to make the right decision with the prospects. So far he’s dealt away the the right prospects. Lindor and Clevinger are two actual star player. There’s a lot of COULD BE with prospects. I have a hard time believing the Indians would deal Clevinger.

More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer

I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

By Mark Timmons · July 17, 202673

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12

3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

By Jeff Dominique · July 16, 202674

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)

It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

By Mark Timmons · July 15, 202652

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor

I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · July 14, 202676