SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Let's Play What If

Apparently the Dodgers need 6 Aces to succeed. Although they have won back to back WS without that luxury. The season is 22 games in, and fans are not happy because Emmet Sheehan (26) is still rounding into form after a very slow start to Spring Training. Every start has…

By Jeff Dominique3 min readJump to 66 comments

Apparently the Dodgers need 6 Aces to succeed.  Although they have won back to back WS without that luxury.  The season is 22 games in, and fans are not happy because Emmet Sheehan (26) is still rounding into form after a very slow start to Spring Training.  Every start has improved over the previous one.  He could have gone 6.0 innings on Saturday, but that is not good enough for a #5 or #6 starter? 

I understand the concerns about Roki Sasaki (24), but I do not believe the Dodgers are going to make a change…at least not until Blake Snell is ready to return. 

I thought the Dodgers should have gone for more SP in the Winter, but most thought the Dodgers had enough depth, and did not want to block any of the youngsters. A very logical argument.

However, we seem to be playing the negative “What If” game, again.  Most have been critical of Sasaki, while many have been critical of Sheehan.  Many are negative towards Alex Freeland (24).  Hyeseong Kim (27) has less directed negativity, but is also subject to his share of negative comments.

I certainly understand the perceived negativity after losing a pair to Colorado.  So let’s continue the negativity that is bound to come about.

Andy Pages is off to a fantastic start.  What if he cannot sustain this pace?  His BABIP is .480, while it was .308 last year.  His K% is up to 26.2% from 21.6% in 2025. 

Are we watching the beginning of the downturn for Mookie Betts?  He got sick last year, but did not have the resurgent energy to get back to where he was.  This year he strained an oblique.  We need to worry about players soft tissue injuries as they begin to age.  What if we begin to see hamstring and groin injuries?

What if Tommy Edman cannot come back to play at an elite level after his ankle surgery.  What if his ankle will not let him adequately roam CF to give Pages a break?  Alex Call can, but what if he is not given an opportunity?

What if Shohei’s power regression continues as he focuses more on pitching?  His SLG is down more than 100 points.  His OPS is down to .915, after the last three years being north of 1.000.

What if Blake Snell cannot pitch well enough to be more than a #6 SP moving Roki Sasaki up to #5?

But what if I prefer to stay more positive?  Let me turn around the what ifs.

What if Tyler Glasnow stays healthy all year?  Who else besides me thinks that Tyler will start 23-26 games this year? 

What if Tommy Edman comes back with a healthy ankle and becomes the elite 2B he was in the WS?  What if he allows Andy Pages to take some valuable games off in the summer, and allows either Freeland or Kim to be a plus platoon partner at 2B?

What if Mookie comes back from the oblique strain and goes on to have a MVP level rest of the season?

What if Andy Pages continues to play elite offense and defense?

What if Dalton Rushing continues hit hot streak and allows for more time off for Will Smith?  Freddie Freeman?

What if Max Muncy has another 35 HR season?

What if Blake Snell comes back and pitches like the 2-time CY Award winner he is?

What if Emmet Sheehan returns to his 2025 form?

What if Justin Wrobleski proves to be a full season SP in the LAD rotation?

And what if Roki Sasaki finds “it”?  Some have pointed out that his velo is way down from last year.  But statcast says that is not true.  His current 4-seam velo is averaging 97.0.  He averaged 96.1 in 2025.  So it is not down.  Is it straighter with less movement?  Maybe. What if he is able to gain command of that fastball and then utilize the splitter and slider to put batters away?

This is just the beginning of a long season, and there will be multiple ebbs and flows throughout the year.  We already know the Dodgers have lost their closer until sometime this summer.  What if Tanner Scott returns to being an elite closer again, after so many gave up on him?

Discussion (66)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. BadgerApril 21, 2026

    Solid input Ted. Some good questions in there. I see a performance like Wrobleski’s as a blueprint. Others should take notice. And as much as Orel’s oreltory bugs me (see what I did there) he made some excellent observations. Two pitches you can locate where you want when you went can get the job done. My coaching early on was high and tight low and away. I could find both spots when I was 12. These guys should be able to do that just like Kersh and Wrobs do. But I suspect the Dodgers, and baseball in general, don’t teach that anymore. With hitting its launch angle and exit velocity, with pitching its velocity and whiff rate. This could be a teaching moment. Other pitchers on this staff might want to consider this strategy. Two who come immediately to mind are Roki and Henriquez. I’m sure there are others.

  2. BlutoApril 21, 2026

    Luke Raley is REALLY crushing it.

  3. BearApril 21, 2026

    Not by far the best record, the Padres are just one game back at 15-7. Last night the 3-4-5 hitters went 1-12. Muncy, Rojas and Rushing were the offense. Who would have guessed that Muncy and Rushing would have more homers than Ohtani. Braves have also won 16 games and they have lost 7. Reds are 15-8, no American League team has more than 13.

  4. BearApril 21, 2026

    A couple of years ago was when Muncy began wearing the glasses. Kike did too and both improved.

  5. tedraymond2.0April 21, 2026

    So far the season has been entertaining with a few disappointments and some nice surprising results. The Dodgers’ record of 16-6 is , by far, the best in baseball. Jeff’s post is wide open for comments depending on how we each look at the play so far. Valid reasons to be critical and reasons for optimism. It’s so early in the season that it can lead to overreactions in both directions. As Badger states above, player stats have a way to regressing to the mean as the season progress. Occasionally, a player will have a break out season. This is what I predicted with Andy Pages as the season began. So far, both offense and defense have gone up a notch or two. Naturally, his CF play has a better chance of continued improvement. And, most likely, his offense will cool off some, but will be better than 2025. It’s nice to finally see the Dodger front office promote and play prospects. Rushing, after a slow start, has been slugging at an other worldly pace the past two weeks. He still has a 30% K rate, but when does put the ball in play the results enough to make his AB’s a must watch. I’m happy to watch Alex Freeland get a solid chance at 2B. His defense has been very good. Offensively, he has had a rough time. He too has been striking out at a 30% clip. So many times he has had men in scoring position and is swinging at very hittable pitches and fails to make contact. That definitely needs to improve if he wants to continue playing in the MLB. I’ll continue to pull for the young man. Roki Sasaki’s 2026 is surprising for me so far. After stellar pitching out of the BP in the postseason I was expecting a strong start to this season. The Dodger pitching “magic” from the coaches has failed him to this point. He has the talent and arm to be a 4-5 starter, but the problem appears to be between his ears right now. The concern about his velo should be secondary to his inability to locate his pitches. How was he so successful in Japan and has had so much trouble transferring that to the MLB? Until Snell returns, I say keep working with him in order to get his mental part of the game on track. Speaking of Snell’s return, when did he get injured? He was out most of last season. He pitched well in the playoffs. Did injury happen then? I wasn’t following the team much in the offseason. How does he go from pitching 17 games at the end of the season, gets injured, and needs the entire offseason and at least the first two months of 2026 to recover? Quite the gig to have making $36MM a season. Kudos to the 6-9 hitters! It’s quite the turnaround from last year when just about everyone was highly critical of the near zero offensive contributions from that group. This year it’s the top of the lineup that hasn’t got on track. It would be fun to see 1-9 hot for two to three weeks of games. Edwin Diaz…. surgery today for bone chips in his elbow. Of course, the curse continues. In 67+ years of watching Dodger baseball I’ve never seen so many pitching injuries as I have the past few seasons. If it wasn’t so upsetting, one can only shake their head. Carry on.

  6. Brian PerkinsApril 21, 2026

    If Max ends up hitting 40 HR, I’m owed an apology.

  7. phil jonesApril 21, 2026

    Another very nice performance by Worbleski. He’s a bullpen saver lately and doing it with only 3 strikeouts. I love seeing a pitcher who can be effective while pitching to contact. Steven Nelson seems bothered by this, quoting in game his lack of swing and miss. Orel, on the other hand, appreciates the skill. 7 innings on 97 pitches is an obvious benefit as well has keeping the defense engaged. I really liked Orel’s comment about Kershaw’s influence on Worbs. Kersh apparently was not a big fan of too many chase pitches, preferring a quality placed competitive pitch to throwing at least 2 and perhaps 3 non-competitive pitches that expand pitch counts. It’s become so predictable now days for a hitter to get down 0 and 2 and then get 2 pitches in the dirt or over his head. Pitchers like Worbs needs to pitch to contact and save the bullets. Nice outing but someone might remind Worbs to back up home on throws from the outfield. In the 5th, Call’s caught a fly and made a nice throw home, holding the runner. Will made a nice block on the throw while Justin watched the game from the middle of the infield. Please get your ass behind home, just in case. Little stuff matters. If a pitcher wanted to get in my doghouse, fail to back up bases or try to be the cut-off man in the middle of the infield, just getting in the way. Muncy and Miggy; have a day. Does anybody remember when Max started wearing his glasses? I’d love to research his stats since he started wearing them.

  8. Brian PerkinsApril 21, 2026

    Let’s beat they ass

  9. Brian PerkinsApril 21, 2026

    Yeah, execs should be meeting right now over coffee and burritos to figure out a way to get Rushing’s bat in the lineup more. There’s Will Smith rest days Freddie Freeman rest days Maybe Ohtani pitching days But there need to be more.

  10. BadgerApril 21, 2026

    What if all that happens? The Dodgers win 125 games. They won’t because it won’t. There will be things that go wrong because things are things and things are designed to go wrong. Anybody that’s alive knows that. Diaz is an example. Sheehan with an ERA of 5.85 and Roki with an ERA of 6.11 are examples of that. Freeland OPS’n .565 is an example. Tucker and Smith haven’t really hit yet. This team is deep and profoundly talented. Numbers will eventually settle into normal ranges. Sheehan and Roki will improve. Dalton Rushing won’t OPS 1.761 and Rojas won’t OPS .950. Somebody else will go on the IL. And I’ll take the under on 26 starts for Glasnow. He’s never done more than 22, so I think that’s a safe bet. I want him there in October. I’m ok with some days off this summer. It’s a long season. This team is built for the playoffs. But in places they are a bit long in the tooth. Don’t push it. 12-3. And it could have been worse. They were 3 for 15 WRISP. It was the Rockies. The Rockies suck begonias The Dodgers are supposed to thump them. SF up next. They suck too. Take it to ‘em.

  11. DanoApril 21, 2026

    Great article Jeff. It gets right to the heart of the matter. Considering most commenters post with their heart. What if we were all Rockies fans. Hmmm. Baseball is a game of futility. So I thoroughly enjoy every successful outcome. Especially when my Dodgers are creating them. Roki is fallible as we all are. But he is a critical component to this dynasty. As is (sorry haters) Landon Knack. Some people are critics and some are cheerleaders. I think you know which one I am. Remember grasshoppers…… He who throws stones hits self in head. Not sure that’s how the saying goes. Oh well. Book em

  12. Mark TimmonsApril 21, 2026

    Great example, Jeff, of how we can see the glass half-full or half-empty. I don’t see any major reason to be worried. Some bad stuff will happen – it always does! But the Dodgers can weather the storm. I have always believed that Andrew Friedman’s decisions, while not always right (whose are?), are generally to be trusted. I do think that Dalton Crushing is forcing the Dodgers’ hand. If Freddie were to go down, Dalton can play there, but that’s it. He’s a catcher. OTOH, Will Smith could play a few games somewhere else (I believe). I think it is incumbent upon the Dodgers to see if Will could play 2B or 3B occasionally. It’s a process… he’s not just going to be penciled in there and deliver. But (in my mind) they should start getting him some reps at 2B or 3 B in practice. Dalton is a little on the “Burley side.” Will is of slighter build… thus the grind wears him down. I’d love to see both their bats in the lineup.

  13. Brian PerkinsApril 21, 2026

    Left shoulder for me. Push-ups are better than bench press though for feeling them. Wrobleski is becoming a storyline unto himself. I always believed in the arm talent. And Rushing, forget it.

  14. Mark TimmonsApril 21, 2026

    I know the feeling. I also could not reach above about 85 degrees. Replaced it in September, and now I have a full range of motion. I don’t do pushups anymore because I have very long monkey arms, and it’s difficult. I’m a knuckle-dragger! 😉

  15. Duke Not SniderApril 21, 2026

    My recollection is that Roki got his velocity back at the end of last season, which helped him perform in the pen. Command seems to be more of a problem now. I’d feel worse about Roki if he was clearly blocking River Ryan right now. But Ryan, Gavin Stone and Snell are all recovering from injuries. The Dodgers brass, it seems, believe in Roki’s talent and are committed to his improvement as an SP for now. But Wrobleski’s rise and, as Jeff suggests, Snell’s return could send him to the pen. (With Diaz out, not a bad outcome.) The Dodgers’ offense is impressive, but Dalton Rushing has been insane. Over 27 ABs, he’s batting .444 with 7–yes, SEVEN–homers. His OPS 1.760. Not bad for a backup catcher. Just for grins, I’m trying to cobble a lineup of Dodger prospect alumni now scattered across the majors DH– Yordan Alvarez C–Fedducia, Ruiz 1B– Busch 2B– Lux 3B– Vargas SS– McKinstry(?) OF– Raley, DeLuca, Outman, Oneil Cruz UT–Jacob Amaya Who am I forgetting?? Some good ones. I hesitate to mention Yonder and Cruz because they were traded as young “lottery tickets”…. who paid off big time. The Dodgers didn’t really “develop” them. Pretty sure I have some loose bodies in my right shoulder. Every time I do pushups, I can hear them grinding.

  16. DodgertifosiApril 21, 2026

    So it has turned out those who thought Edwin diaz might be injured were spot on. Will have surgery for loose bodies in his elbow tomorrow. Out indefinetely. Bummer for sure. That will force the Dodgers to reset their bullpen with their closer down. Closer by committee again ? Likely. On Sasaki: Jeff, you wrote that somebody wroet that Sasakis velo was down from last season and statcast shows otherwise. I can only speak for myself but I wrote yesterday that his velo was down considerably from his days in Japan, not last year.

More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer

I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

By Mark Timmons · July 17, 202673

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12

3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

By Jeff Dominique · July 16, 202674

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)

It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

By Mark Timmons · July 15, 202652

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor

I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · July 14, 202676