SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

It All Starts With Freddie & Mookie

I have a few minutes before I leave for my surgery, so I thought I would drop you a few notes. By the way, thank you for all the kind words and well wishes. Now, let’s do this! As Dodger fans, we spend many of our waking hours thinking about who to blame for the Dodger’s start…

By Mark Timmons3 min read35 comments

I have a few minutes before I leave for my surgery, so I thought I would drop you a few notes. By the way, thank you for all the kind words and well wishes. Now, let’s do this!

As Dodger fans, we spend many of our waking hours thinking about who to blame for the Dodger’s start. We really don’t have to invent anything. All we need to do is look at the Dodgers Stars, who happen to be their highest-paid players. Of course, I am talking about Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman. Both players have been described as Team Leaders who lead by their actions, and if that is the case, we need to realize that neither player is earning their keep.

  • Max Muncy has more RBIs than Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman – COMBINED!
  • Rookie James Outman has 20 RBIs, which is exactly the same as Max and Freddie – COMBINED!
  • Will Smith has 13 RBIs in 50 ABs, while Freddie has 9 RBIs in 113 ABs.
  • David Peralta (whom many of you want to throw on the scrap heap) has 10 RBIs in 50 fewer ABs than Freddie Freeman.
  • CT3 has 11 RBIs in about 50 fewer ABs than Mookie, who also has 11!

If this team is going to contend, then the Stars of the Show (Mookie and Freddie) are going to have to deliver… and they simply have not! Of course, we need as much as each player can deliver, but it all starts with the stars! They lead and light the way.

Rants & Raves

  • It was nice to sweep the Cardinals, but they are struggling, and it should have been done.
  • Thor looks like he is finished. He was hitting 95 last year and thought the Dodgers could get him back to 100 MPH. I don’t think I have seen any more than 92. Gavin Stone is going to force him out. This may be an obvious bad signing. AF might as well cut bait now. Gavin Stone to the rescue! Syndergaard may have gotten his first win, but his pitching is untenable!
  • I am pretty sure that Alex Vesia told Doc, “Thanks for trusting me,” yesterday when he brought in the Bazooka. Sometimes when a player is pitching badly, the confidence shown in him can breed confidence. Doc did that to Vesia and Almonte yesterday, and that might just turn their seasons around.
  • David Peralta is hitting .167, but he makes every opportunity count. He was 0-4 yesterday but plated two runs. That’s a professional hitter… now, just add some hits, David!
  • The Bazooka – 2.19 ERA!
  • Andre Jackson struggles early every year to find his release point and then is lights out. He got smoked again at AAA yesterday. When he is right, his stuff is filthy. He’s just not right consistently.
  • Jonny DeLuca was 3-5 with his 6th HR and 3 RBI.
  • Andy Pages was 2-5.
  • Finally, Diego Cartaya was 3-5!
  • Nick Frasso – 4 IP, 1 H, 4 K’s. I could see him pitching for LA in relief this year!
  • By the way, the Apple TV Friday night production was College Level at best. I thought it was a disgrace, but I have a son, stepdaughter, and a son-in-law who are all in the film industry, so maybe I am too critical. It was awful!

Discussion (35)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. Mark TimmonsMay 2, 2023

    It’s rare (not impossible) that rookie players’ strikeouts go down that much. There is no way on God’s Green Earth that he will have a 42% strikeout rate and a good OB%. More about this tomorrow.

  2. EricMay 2, 2023

    Here’s the solution. Give Betts SS permanently. Give Busch LF. Give Smith DH. Platoon Taylor with one of the trio of outfielders that only hit RHP in RF. Make Martinez a pinch-hitter. Bring up Feduccia at C.

  3. Duke Not SniderMay 2, 2023

    Just caught a snippet from Trea Turner interview on DodgerBlue’s YouTube site.

    Re Mookie:

    “He just plays a different rightfield–the way he cuts off baseballs, his throws are so accurate.”

    Trea also said when Lux got injured he thought Mookie might eventually move to SS, because “he’s a freak” and that he knew that Mookie loved playing 2B.

    Dodgers now up 8-1, and Gonsolin cruising, showing why he was an all-star last year.

  4. WayneMay 2, 2023

    Mike Busch has a sweet swing, he looks the part.

  5. Ron Fairly fanMay 2, 2023

    Glad you’re back Mark I everything went well and you have a quick recovery. I don’t know about anybody else I wish they would put Betts somewhere and just leave him there. I think him bouncing around might be some of the reason for his slow start.

    Put him at short and leave him there. Let Rojas fill in around the infield to give guys days off.

    Let Thompson and Taylor filter in and out of the lineup. Put Busch as the DH and leave him there with Smith giving him days off against tough lefties. You need to see what you have in Busch.

  6. Duke Not SniderMay 2, 2023

    Nice to see Smith back behind the plate and Busch getting the start at 2B, with Vargas taking the DH spot.

    Also nice that Mookie is back at SS, which allows Heyward to start at RF. Over the past 15 days, Heyward has compiled a .412 and OPS of .805. Plus his defense out there is nearly equal to Mookie’s.

    Compare Heyward’s recent numbers to Taylor’s. Even though he just had a two-hit game, Taylor had an OPB of .233 and OPS of .578 over the past 15 days. One reason for Heyward’s recent surge: He has walked 6 times and struck out only 4 times in that period, while Taylor walked once and K’d 14 times.

    I agree with folks here who think that Thompson, with his reverse splits, is interchangeable with Peralta. Peralta has a much better track record, but perhaps Thompson’s numbers suck because the Dodger management force him to bat against lefties.

    Anyway, I think one will be gone at midseason–and if Busch makes the most of his opportunity now, maybe he’ll be able to stay.

    Just noticed that Smith returned with a homer, and Peralta delivered one too. Nice.

  7. Mark TimmonsMay 2, 2023

    Ladies and Gentlemen,

    DAVID PERALTA (aka/”The Freight Train”)

  8. EricMay 2, 2023

    Good to hear from you Mark and good to hear you are doing ok. I’ve had plenty of surgeries in my lifetime so I’m glad you are doing ok.

  9. CassidyMay 2, 2023

    Good to have you back Mark

  10. BlunderfullMay 2, 2023

    May May

    https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRwAN9UC/

  11. BoboMay 2, 2023

    Well hopefully you can get good rest and recover quickly. Glad things went well, and without too much pain.

    And enjoy a Dodger win tonight.

  12. BoboMay 2, 2023

    How you feeling ?

  13. Mark TimmonsMay 1, 2023

    Rumors of my demise were greatly exaggerated!

  14. Andrew Vincent ForteMay 1, 2023

    Dodgers activate Miguel Rojas off injured list, designate Austin Wynns for assignment

  15. Andrew Vincent ForteMay 1, 2023

    Sunday scores

    Oklahoma City 9, Sacramento 4 (Game 1)

    Sacramento 5, Oklahoma City 1 (Game 2)

    Tulsa 11, Arkansas 10 (10 innings)

    Great Lakes 5, Fort Wayne 2

    Rancho Cucamonga 13, Inland Empire 8

    Tuesday schedule

    8:05 a.m. PT: Great Lakes (TBD) vs. Quad Cities [Royals] (TBD)

    11 a.m.: Rancho Cucamonga (Peter Heubeck) at Lake Elsinore [Padres] (Henry Baez)

    4:05 p.m.: Tulsa (TBD) vs. San Antonio [Padres] (TBD)

    5:35 p.m.: Oklahoma City (Robbie Erlin) at El Paso [Padres] (TBD)

  16. MushersPopMay 1, 2023

    A few stats (eg K rate) do stabilize in under 80 ABs, but for things like SLG and OBP it’s 300–400+ ABs and for batting average it’s over 900.

    Obviously the Dodgers aren’t going to give Thompson 900 at bats. But the more they can give him the better to determine his true potential.

  17. Andrew Vincent ForteMay 1, 2023

    10:10 PM ET

    Phillies (15-14)

    Dodgers (16-13) tied for 1st

    SP Taijuan Walker R

    2-1 4.97 ERA 25.1P 23K

    SP Tony Gonsolin R

    0-0 .00 ERA 3,1IP 1K

    Confirmed Lineup

    SS Mookie Betts R

    1B F. Freeman L

    C Will Smith R

    3B Max Muncy L

    RF J. Heyward L

    CF James Outman L

    DH M. Vargas R

    LF D. Peralta L

    2B M. Busch L

    Cloudy

    35% Precipitation

    59° Wind 9 mph Out

  18. philjonesMay 1, 2023

    In a not so small sample size, like 2022, Trayce had 159 AB’s vs RHP and hit .308. In 86 AB’s vs LHP he hit .174. Yet we continue to insist he platoon to face LHP. It ain’t working. I’m not sure what sample size they need to stop the experiment.

  19. EricMay 1, 2023

    It’s still a small sample but Thompson against RHP .250/.375/.700/1.075 I think one of Heyward or Peralta need to go in favor of an outfielder somewhere that can hit LHP. But that’s asking Doc to look at splits.

  20. 4-GensMay 1, 2023

    I feel like the Dodgers are forcing the issue with Trace by saying “you need to hit lefties to be on the roster.” I think he will be the first to be cut/sent down.

  21. OldBear48May 1, 2023

    Umpires so far have been awful. Wolf, usually a pretty good umpire blew some easy calls yesterday. Max should be pissed. Got approval for my eye surgery. Should happen sometime in May. Play of the day yesterday was the dad with the baby and a beer catching a foul ball.

  22. MattMay 1, 2023

    And where has Joe Davis been????

  23. MattMay 1, 2023

    Freddie has as many stolen bases as Trea Turner….

  24. philjonesMay 1, 2023

    * Did Syndergaard have any swings and misses? I don’t recall many. He had no strike outs in 5.1

    He has NO stuff. He seems like a victim of bad luck with seeing eye grounders, a check swing double, chinkers here and dunkers there, but he misses no bats. That much contact is going to produce traffic. Doc even left him in to face to the 2 right hand bats in the 6th after wiggling out of trouble in the 5th. Our offense just kept getting the lead back for him. I guess the Baseball Gods decided it was time to get Thor a win.

    I personally have never warmed up to the guy. I root for him as a Dodger but it’s like rooting for Drago in Rocky IV.

    * Geez our guys get into serious “ pull-mode”. We pull way too many pitches away and roll over way too much.

    * Jim Wolf is usually a consistent HPU with a small zone. He had some kind of psychogenic fugue in the 4th when every pitch was a strike. He really needs to clean up his mechanics on signals for clock violations. Nobody knows the count or what’s going on.

    * Doc / the Wizard seem to be insistent on this Heyward / Thompson platoon at the plate. It doesn’t work because of Thompson’s reverse splits we all know about.

    Thompson predictably pinch hit for Heyward, bottom 7 to face LHP and struck out. Trayce is being asked to do what he can’t; hit LHP. They even showed a graphic on the screen. He’s hitting .083 against LHP yet that’s his roll. He’s hitting .250 vs RHP, while Heyward is at .239 vs RHP. This platoon doesn’t work offensively. Our outfield is awful in general versus LHP. CT3 .158, Heyward 0 (0 for 3), Mookie .208, Peralta .400 (2 for 5). Outman at .333 (and .280 vs RHP) should never platoon.

    * I’d love to see Outman learn to slide feet first on both sides of his body. His left hip slide exposes his face to catcher’s throws. Sliding on either side allows him to keep his face from being exposed from outfield throws on the left side and catcher’s throws on the right hip. I learned to do it years ago and my face still looks real good……I think.

    * If you’re looking for evidence of what a shitty manager of the bullpen Doc is, don’t look to yesterday for evidence. Doc’s use of Vesia, Graterol versus Goldy, Almonte and Phillips to close was great use of the right pitchers in the right situations and not just a guy labeled by inning.

    * I’ve had my criticisms about some Doc moves at times but he needs to get credit as well when he makes good decisions.

    It doesn’t hurt that his guys executed their jobs and did what they’re paid to do either.

  25. BlutoMay 1, 2023

    RBIs are a lame stat.

    That said, both will be fine in the long run.

  26. EricMay 1, 2023

    Maybe Betts and Freeman aren’t getting RBIs because they’re hitting one and two behind the end of the order that can’t hit if their life depended on it. I talked about this when the season first started.

    1 Outman

    2 Smith

    3 Freeman

    4 Betts

    5 Muncy

    And then go from there.

    I also said before the season started that I had question marks about 2B SS LF DH and those positions have turned out to be the problem so far. I assumed Betts would be in RF obviously.

    Freeman is doing pretty good so Betts is the problem of the 2 superstars.

  27. SpokaneBobMay 1, 2023

    Praying for you to have successful surgery and a speedy recovery.

    Thank you so much for providing LADT to all of us Dodger Fans.

  28. Gerald PerryMay 1, 2023

    Thanks for your great site Mark – safe and speedy recovery for you on the surgery. Here is something you may want to consider to help in the recovery process. We took my wife, 74 years old then, to Montana for her hip replacement 5 years ago as the wait list here in Alberta was a couple of years. A very good friend who is from a medical family told her to start on Arnica Montana. When we went in to the herbal store in Whitefish, the lady asked why are you buying this, explained the hip, and she yes the Arnica will help the flesh/muscles to heal but you need Symphytum to help the bones heal. 5 little pills each every 6 hours for three weeks. Asked her surgeon about it and he said you may do what ever you want after surgery but please do what I ask before. When my wife went into her first physio appointment 6 weeks later, the physio said she had never seen anyone with the range of movement she had so soon after surgery. She did the same three years later for her second hip replacement, same result. I did the same for both my bunion surgeries, same result. Recommended the treatment for a lady at our bridge club with her knee replacement and she won’t stop thanking me. It can’t hurt – good luck to both you and the Dodgers.

  29. CassidyMay 1, 2023

    I can live with 16-13 and tied for first and not playing anywhere near our best. The Yankees at 15-14 in last and 8 games back. We’ve been fortunate the Pads have also been slow out of the gate. Better days ahead. Speedy recovery Mark. Can B&P fill in to chastize us until you’re back?

  30. DavidMay 1, 2023

    The other way to look at this is we are in first place WITHOUT our two best hitters contributing, and pitching sub par. You would have to think they will turn it around. Remember all those years JT started horribly.

  31. FallitoMay 1, 2023

    Speedy recovery!

    The thing with Thor is seams he is making so easy to the opponents to hit. look at yesterday. We manage to get the lead 3-2 playing small ball and next inning to batters and it is tie again. So frustrating.

  32. Mark TimmonsMay 1, 2023

    Tim Bachman of Bachman Turner Overdrive, dead at 71!

  33. Andrew Vincent ForteMay 1, 2023

    LA Designates Catcher Austin Wynns for Assignment

    Considering they’ll need to replace him with a position player, the move should mean the return of Miguel Rojas off the 10-day IL.Rojas just completed a 2 game rehab stint with the Rancho Cucamonga Quakes where he went 2-6 with a home run.

  34. Andrew Vincent ForteMay 1, 2023

    Prayers and thoughts are with you. You’ll come out 100% better feeling like you did when you were in your 20s.

  35. Anthony HMay 1, 2023

    I am sending good thoughts your way Mark! Best wishes for a speedy recovery!

More from Dodger Talk

Nothing Wrong With Back of the Rotation SP for LAD

I said it when Roki Sasaki was struggling…If not Roki, who? He finally started to pitch with more confidence and he put together a string of positive starts. Yes, there were those who forgot about his previous four excellent starts and instead focused on his CWS start. He is a…

By Jeff Dominique · June 16, 202670

Who Bats Where?

A good percentage of comments on this blog relate to “who bats where” in the batting order. “Shohei should bat cleanup.” “ Freddie should be the number three hitter.” “No, Freddie should hit second.” “Max Muncy should hit cleanup.” “Mookie should hit 9th.” … and on and on… Where…

By Mark Timmons · June 15, 2026104

Happy, Hopeful, Blessed, and Thankful

I grew up in Ohio and lived there until 1976, when I was 23 years old. I have been in Indiana for 50 years, so I consider myself a Hoosier. Now, I actually live 45 minutes from Bloomington, where the IU Hoosiers play. However, since I was nine years old, I have been a Dodger…

By Mark Timmons · June 14, 2026123

Are You True Blue?

What do I mean by true blue? Well, over the years I have seen my share of bandwagon and fair-weather fans. True blue fans stick with the team no matter what. Their allegiance to the team never waivers. Not when a favorite is traded or lost to free agency, not when the team…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · June 13, 202693