SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Is it Verlander Time?

I have consistently said that I do not think the Dodgers need bullpen help. Since June 20th, the Dodger bullpen has been the best in baseball, and if only two or three of the pitchers on the IL come back from injury, there is absolutely no need. I also think it is foolish to…

By Mark Timmons2 min readJump to 136 comments

I have consistently said that I do not think the Dodgers need bullpen help. Since June 20th, the Dodger bullpen has been the best in baseball, and if only two or three of the pitchers on the IL come back from injury, there is absolutely no need. I also think it is foolish to believe that two starters like Giolito and Stroman will help the Dodgers win a championship. The Dodgers need an Ace that can win at least two games in a seven-game series. The only one out there who fits that bill is Justin Verlander. It just might be time for him to come to the Dodgers.

I have hope that Julio Urias will figure out his mechanics and release point, but I am not confident that I will live that long. 😉 Clayton Kershaw will be back, and I have no difficulty believing that he will pick up where he left off. Bobby Miller belongs in the rotation, and the mystery is Tony Gonsolin. He is the weak link, but as a #4 or #5, he is fine. Michael Grove, who also might be a horse there!

However, the Dodgers need a “HORSE” at the top of their rotation, and it appears that the only possibility of finding one is to look at Justin Verlander. After some arm issues at the beginning of the season, he has returned to form or close to it. He is not striking out as many hitters, but that means fewer pitches which may be a good thing. In his last seven games, he has a 2.05 ERA, has averaged almost seven innings each game, and has a 1.07 WHIP.

Look, at his age, it is a risk, but it would not take a lot in prospect collateral – All the Dodgers have to do is pay the man his Big Bux. Verlander is owed the remainder of his $43.333 Million Contract this year and another $43.333 Million next year. The Dodgers could probably get him for a song with just a few (probably lower-level) prospects. I have no idea who and if the Mets would do it, but with a $330,000,000 payroll and a sinking ship, I think the Mets would listen. The Giants also could do the same thing, but in a bidding war, the Dodgers have better prospects and an abundance of them.

How would this be for a rotation?

  1. Verlander
  2. Kersahw
  3. Urias
  4. Miller
  5. Gonsolin

With a bullpen of eight of the following (Pick ’em):

  1. Almonte
  2. Bickford
  3. Brasier
  4. Ferguson
  5. Graterol
  6. Grove
  7. T. Miller
  8. Phillips
  9. Sheehan
  10. Vesia
  11. Bruihl
  12. Feyereisen
  13. Gonzalez
  14. Hudson
  15. Pepiot
  16. Nelson
  17. Stone
  18. Treinen
  19. Buehler

Eight – all they need are 8. Some will not return healthy, but some will. All the Dodgers need are 8! If they can’t get EIGHT good relievers out of that bunch, I am Betty Crocker!

I get Kike Hernandez. I don’t get Rosario! But Friedman is not done. I do not know how in the hell AF got the Indians to take Thor! He must have photos of someone. I have a feeling he is working on something… we shall soon know!

But, I think it is Verlander Time!

Discussion (136)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. BobbyJuly 27, 2023

    Angele acquire Lucas Gialito

  2. Mark TimmonsJuly 27, 2023

    The Dodgers are allegedly interested in bringing Joe Kelly back.

  3. WayneJuly 27, 2023

    “He must have photos of someone.” – lol

    Yes, Rosario a head-scratcher, but maybe he can play 2B instead of SS ?

  4. Johnny GentleJuly 27, 2023

    Nope

  5. Singing The BlueJuly 27, 2023

    I agree that we need an Ace and Verlander seems like the only possible solution.

    Cohen would rather pay down half his salary and demand more prospect capital from us. He doesn’t care about the money and he won’t sell just to keep from paying Verlander’s salary.

    The potential problem is that Verlander’s arm falls off the day after we get him…………………but I guess we may have to take that chance. We need to add a really good pitcher, one way or the other.

  6. DodgfanJuly 27, 2023

    Lynn got lit up again. We just got rid of Thor. I don’t have the stomach for another washed up SP. Verlander OTH, is an intriguing proposition.

  7. DodgerfanJuly 27, 2023

    No talk of a RH bat

  8. DodgerHorseJuly 27, 2023

    Luis Rodríguez (20), Wilman Díaz (19), Josué De Paula (18) are doing very well !!!

  9. DodgerHorseJuly 27, 2023

    Trading Verlander would put the Mets in a better position to land Ohtani as FA, I don’t see the Dodgers loocking for Verlander because that situation.

    Andrew Friedman plays chess

  10. Mark TimmonsJuly 27, 2023

    Hunter Feduccia is hitting .301 with a .913 OPS.

  11. norcaldodgerfanJuly 27, 2023

    After watching Gonsolin pitch yesterday it is apparent we need SP big time. I was hoping for Giolito, but if we can get Cohen to pay some of Verlander’s salary I hope AF swings that deal.

    I still think Arenado is a possibility that I put at 50/50.

  12. dodgerpatchJuly 27, 2023

    I can only speculate about the Rosario trade, but it might be a combination of finding a way to get something for Syndergaard – and getting rid of Syndergaard solves a problem – and the Dodgers thinking they can resurrect Rosario. Rosario was once the 3rd highest rated prospect in all of baseball. He had a 65 FV rating from Fangraphs, who are stingy. He was always considered a defense first infielder, but his defense has taken a nosedive this year. He’s still only 27. Maybe a change of scenery might help. At the least, he’s a project, and even if he doesn’t make an impact this year, would be an infield option for next year if he can turn things around.

    I’d take a chance on Verlander. I like Mark’s thinking here. Yeah, his K rate is way down, and his BB rate is up, but if recent trends are an indicator, maybe he’s finding his feel for the strike zone again. His fastball velo is exactly where it was in 2019 when he went 21-6 and won the Cy Young, so it’s not like age and innings have finally diminished his velocity.

    Looking at that collection of pitchers, you realize what I triage ward the staff has been. Don’t hear much about Hudson, but guessing he doesn’t make it back – although it’s still a long shot, as is Trienen. Jimmy Nelson is pitching. He would be a huge boost if he came back throwing 94 MPH. He hasn’t pitched since 2021. The Dodgers are paying him 1.2 mil.

  13. Andrew Vincent ForteJuly 27, 2023

    Barnes catches and another loss to add to the pile of losses when he does.

  14. CassidyJuly 27, 2023

    If Urias and Gonsolin don’t figure it out, then it won’t make any difference who we sign at the deadline. Who would have thought this of our starting rotation at the beginning of the year? Injured, injured, aweful, aweful and aweful!

  15. OldBear48July 27, 2023

    The pool of starting pitchers who are actually available. Lynn, Montgomery, Flaherty, Stroman, possibly Kendrick and Verlander. Mets have not made up their mind yet, Scherzer if Mets decide to sell, Rodriguez of the Tigers, Greinke, Hill, and possibly any other starter on the teams that are out of the race who is on a one-year deal.

  16. BobbyJuly 27, 2023

    Hey Matt, sorry if I came across as rude yesterday about our Kershaw topic.

    But, happy to debate October Kershaw anytime with you! Go Rams!!

  17. dodgerramJuly 27, 2023

    I like the Rosario trade. If only it got rid of Thor.

    The Verlander idea I support. We need an ace and if VErlanders arm holds up he is that ace.

    Angels holding on to Ohtani is a good thing for the Dodgers. First none of the other NL contenders get him and second we now can go after him in free agency without another team having the pole position because they traded for him.

    Go Dodgers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  18. TMJuly 27, 2023

    I don’t know….it seems to me the dodgers are frantically scrambling to add missing pieces and instead are adding guys with baggage and not really much better than the guys we have.

    I for one am very happy with Rojas’ play this year. Great glove and does enough with the stick. Not doing much worse than Tre Turner with the stick.

    I’m okay with losing Thor but we do need pitching. If you are talking about 40:year old Verlander….why would you want his contract for next year let alone the remainder of this year?

    Like I said, it seems like our management is making moves just to show we are doing something. Kike and Rosario don’t seem any better to me than Rojas and CT3.

  19. sbuffaloJuly 27, 2023

    The Nolan Arenado rumors are persisting. Maybe they will trade him if the return is right. Would the Dodgers be willing to pay that price? That would be the biggest trade deadline deal and would definitely shake things up.

    But unless things change, the Dodgers have a rotation problem. Verlander might help, if the Mets are inclined to trade him. Right now they seem content to keep him and Scherzer and play for 2024.

    But if not Verlander, who?

    Jordan Montgomery or Jack Flaherty. Dylan Cease, probably not. Blake Shell is doing pretty well, but the Padres wouldn’t trade him to the Dodgers. Then there is Eduardo Rodriquez, but that’s complicated. Marcus Stroman will probably be traded, but he’s been pretty bad in his last five starts.

    Perhaps the best available pitcher is Montgomery, a lefty from St. Louis. Package him with Arenado and you have something to talk about. Bad last outing, but previous eight starts were good. Lance Lynn, no way. I really like Flaherty, good outings in his last eleven starts. Or Michael Lorenzen, very good in July.

    I’m guessing the Dodgers will be very active. It would nice if Julio Urias figures it out and pitches well consistently. But I won’t hold my breath.

    On the hitting side, the Dodgers could use a right handed bat with big time pop. But that means Arenado. Otherwise you’re working the fringes of the trade market.

  20. dodgerrickJuly 27, 2023

    1 – What Arenado rumors? There’s almost nothing about him except for wishful thinking from some on this site.

    2 – How does Arenado solve the Dodgers’ most pressing problems? They need starting pitching most. And they have a 3B already. What do they do with Muncy? Surely not 2B.

    3 – Kyle Hendrick hasn’t had an ERA below 3.55 since 2016. Last year he was 4-6, 4.82. 2021, he had a 4.77 ERA and led the league in hits allowed. This year he has struck out 46 in 70 IP. He’s not a big upgrade really.

    I still view this as a transitional year. The Dodgers don’t need to add payroll for 2024. They have half a lineup and half a rotation and shouldn’t go too far in the postseason anyway. They will probably lose Urias this offseason and no one knows if Kershaw’s coming back, if Buehler can return successfully as a starting pitcher after a 2nd Tommy John, if or when May returns from his second elbow surgery in 3 years. Even Lux is a question mark next year. And they don’t appear to have a 2B.

    Peralta, Heyward, and JD Martinez are free agents.

    In short, they will have to rebuild the rotation and outfield and the middle infield.

    So don’t do anything this year that screws up the ability to rebuild next year.

  21. Duke Not SniderJuly 27, 2023

    Still loving those persistent Arenado rumors, mostly because there’s a logic to the last-place Cards doing a bold rebuild.

    If they deal Arenado, they shed more than $100 million in salary over the next four years, and their No. 1 prospect replaces Arenado at 3B. Their OF talent logjam gets eased.

    Most importantly, the Cards would get a handsome return for a star in his prime, which could start with Cartaya and 3 top pitching prospects with years of contract control. The Cards would get their payroll in check.

    The Dodgers would also seek Montgomery or Flaherty, and perhaps return Max, since he’d lose his 3B gig. Or maybe offer JDM, with Max sliding to DH. A lot of possible permutations. Dodgers could seek an outfielder, since Heyward and Peralta aren’t getting younger.

    Odds of something like this happening?

    Oh.. maybe 30-1.

    But it’s fun to dream a bit….

  22. Duke Not SniderJuly 27, 2023

    Just a few thoughts while waiting for Verlander….

    —A few times here I’ve criticized the notion that a team “gave up” on a player after a trade is executed. But the phrase seems perfectly apt for the Syndergaard deal. Last season, Thor was a decent back-of-the-rotation starter. The Angels traded Thor to the Phillies for former No. 1 overall pick Mickey Moniak, who has finally had his breakout season for the Angels. (Perhaps fair to say the Phils “gave up” on Moniak.) Thor pitched meaningful innings for the Phils, helping them get to the WS. Then signed with Dodgers hoping that Prior & Company could help him get back to his old dominant self. But here we are: The Dodgers desperately need an SP or two, and they must be 100% convinced that Thor isn’t that guy.

    –So flipping him and a few million bucks to Cleveland for Rosario seems like a pretty good deal. Rosario can platoon with Rojas and otherwise be a strong option off the bench against lefties. Last season, AF foolishly placed his faith in an untested rookie, Vargas, but it’s better to have tried-and-true veterans as role players. Rosario and Kike should be useful, especially against lefties.

    –While I cling to the dream of Arenado, my hopes for a Lane Thomas deal seem misplaced. That notion was predicated on the belief that Mookie would move to 2B full-time, with Thomas coming in to take over RF. So maybe the Dodgers just aren’t ready to move Mookie, although Mookie seems ready.

    –My hunch is that the Dodgers will deal for Lance Lynn, Jordan Montgomery or Flaherty and pass on Stroman or Eduardo Rodriguez, whose option clauses create financial uncertainty. Dodgers want to limit payroll commitments for the Ohtani pursuit. The exception would be Arenado’s contract, since getting a gold glover would make be extra incentive for Ohtani to wear Dodgers blue.

    –Ohtani can easily command at $65mm AAV. Maybe $70 mm. Hell, that’s about what Jaylen Brown signed for with the Celtics–and he ain’t a household name like Lebron or Steph Curry Look at the money the top soccer stars are getting. Ohtani is a global superstar and will obliterate the baseball salary records.

  23. BlutoJuly 27, 2023

    David Vassegh (informed source or not?) recently opined that the acquisitions of Kike and Rosario may be setting the table to trade Chris Taylor?

    Another indicator that the team is trying to get the payroll down? Idle speculation? Interesting trade component?

  24. Mark TimmonsJuly 27, 2023

    My point today is that if you can’t get a Top-of-the-Rotation guy, you stay home!

    All of the starters on the market today have warts. Stroman has a 7.00+ ERA in his last 7 starts.

    Lynn – 5.95 ERA in his last 7 games

    Flaherty – 4.91 ERA in the last 7 games.

    Jordon Montgomery is the best of that bunch, but he has always been a middle-of-the rotation guy.

    Those guys won’t make that much difference. Stay with what you have. But there is only one Ace who may be available – Verlander, and his ERA is 2.05 in the last 7 games.

    Go Big or Don’t bother.

    Rosario is just a flyer on an underperforming player and AF somehow got rid of Thor in the process!

  25. philjonesJuly 27, 2023

    * This is really not my favorite time of the season. I’m a baseball guy and I like to watch games and root for the team. I’m not a GM and that is not a burning issue for me to speculate who’s coming and who’s going. I’m always relieved when we can settle back without all the rumors flying and try to enjoy some baseball on the field and try to win a Division.

    * That said it’s hard for me not to scratch my head over the few recent transactions. I have to think there will be a bigger deal in the near future. Other then ridding ourselves of Noah, I have no idea what Rosario brings to the dance? I scoffed earlier when Bradley was all over him. I also said Kike’s ship had sailed. What do I know?

    * Most of you who have read my posts over the years know that I like to comment on how the game is played, coaching decisions and especially issues from a player’s perspective. These guys aren’t robots.

    * Some, like Mark, like Kike and liked this deal. Not so much for me.

    Kike is 31. He’s batting .222 (66-for-297) with 11 doubles, six homers and 31 RBI in 76 games with the Red Sox. I assume he was acquired by the Dodgers to face LHP. He only has 77 at bats vs lefties but he’s hitting .260 / .652 with a homer. That would put him in the platoon picture vs LHP in the outfield with Mookie, Outman and CT3. So, his first start back is at 2nd and not in the outfield. I’d much rather have Mookie at 2nd and Kike in the outfield. Now add Rosario and my mind shuts down.

    * As mentioned, there isn’t much of a risk or financial cost for Kike’s deal so it’s like kissing your sister.

    On the flip side Jonny Deluca is the casualty. It was fortunate timing that Jonny pulled a hammie in the 8th inning of the game prior to Kike’s arrival. He could go on the IL and the Dodgers didn’t have to send him to OKC, which I’m sure was plan B, after the muscle pull. He’s gotten in 23 games and 40 at bats. He made some outstanding defensive plays recently and has nice speed. He’s been on the 26 man since June 7th and has hit .275 / .776 and has shown nice contact skills with a K rate of 20%. He’s hit .300 / .797 vs LHP, which has been his platoon. Not that bad.

    * On one hand, it can’t hurt and Kike helps us…….or doesn’t. On the surface it’s a harmless experiment. Something the organization loves to do.

    * On the other hand, it isn’t harmless for Jonny Deluca. Or other mid 20’s prospects waiting their turn.

    Are we, or are we not, committed to seeing the youngsters this season? This is now further compounded with the arrive of Rosario. Are we committed to giving our kids a fair look? Did Jonny get a fair look? I don’t see 40 at bats as a legit shot.

    * Are we in a Transition Year? Or half of a Transition Year.

    If the Braintrust is convinced that Deluca is another 25 year old AAAA player that won’t help us, then fine. Make all the moves you want at the deadline and we move forward. But, I’m not convinced. I think we are changing horses in the middle of the stream for no good reason. Why would we add expensive payroll now, with Verlander contract, when an obvious goal is to cut payroll? I don’t see that one.

    And I think it’s a disservice to say we’re going to see the youngsters and assess for their futures and then dump veterans on top of them.

    It’s not hard to be demoralizing if this was going to be your chance for guys like Deluca. Our prospects can easily think, WTF? Do I have a shot in this organization or not. It’s easy to figure why a prospect could think “screw it” with the Dodgers. Get me to an organization where I’ll have a fair shot to show my game.

    * Players will tell you they don’t think that way. They are resigned to FATE. They will say they don’t worry about stuff out of their control. That they can only control their own effort. It sounds so mature.

    They will say that in interviews to the public and try to convince themselves. All the while, I know that’s bullshit.

    I have zero clue what AF is up to. But I don’t know what he’s up to or what our identity is. We’ll know soon enough.

More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer

I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

By Mark Timmons · July 17, 202673

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12

3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

By Jeff Dominique · July 16, 202674

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)

It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

By Mark Timmons · July 15, 202652

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor

I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · July 14, 202676