SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Half Full or Half Empty?

A glass containing water to the half-way point is often used to point out the difference between optimists and pessimists: The optimist sees the glass as half full. They focus on what is there. “ So much that can be done with half a glass of water.” The pessimist sees the glass…

By Mark Timmons3 min read16 comments

A glass containing water to the half-way point is often used to point out the difference between optimists and pessimists:

The optimist sees the glass as half full. They focus on what is there. “So much that can be done with half a glass of water.”

The pessimist sees the glass as half empty. He sees that the glass used to be full and now half of its contents are gone. Soon it will be empty. And he will be thirsty. Woe is me!

If you want to get deep into any analysis of Glass Half Full or Glass Half Empty, there are really more choices than that. How about these?

So, the pessimist may look at the Dodgers’ infield defense and say, “The Left Side of the Dodgers’ infield is not championship caliber,” while the optimist may say, “When was the last time Mookie failed at anything?” My father was the best bowler I have personally ever seen. He owned a bowling alley when I was a kid, and his best game was a 299. Mookie has bowled several perfect 300 games! As an athlete, Mookie focuses on something and masters it. By the end of this season, he will be recognized as the best SS in all of baseball. There, I said it!

Gavin Lux is showing all of the signs that his throwing problems (aka, The YIPS) are ancient history, and I see him breaking out BIG TIME at 2B. Freddie Freeman is Gold Glove Worthy at 1B, Gavin Lux is also capable of that at 2B, and Mookie will be there soon enough. Don’t worry about Max Muncy! He will be fine.

Bullpen Deliema

J. P. Feyereisen is currently on the IL but will be added (maybe as soon as today) for either Michael Grove or Kyle Hurt.  Also, Blake Treinen and the Bazooka will come off the IL, and two more pitchers will have to go down or to the IL. This is the pitching roster as of RIGHT NOW:

So what three pitchers will come off when JP, Blake, and Bazooka return (which will be soon)? Also, there are two lefties in the pen )Vedia and Yarbrough) – will that be enough?

Today is Opening Day, but the Dodgers start the season 1-1. That is crazy!

Will Smith Expended

It had to happen. The Dodgers gave him a 10-year deal, which is the longest ever for a catcher, in exchange for a low AAV ($14 Million). You have heard it here for a long time, but Will Smith will likely catch for just two more years… maybe less. The Dodgers have four catchers who are in hot pursuit of his job and you would be remiss to give up on Diego Cartaya just yet. His talent, leadership, and character are off the charts. Many of you gave up on Gavin Stone, but you can never fully understand player development if you think it is linear.

https://twitter.com/SportsNetLA/status/1772825033234428255?s=20

Discussion (16)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. CassidyMarch 29, 2024

    Is it too early to say that the Angels season is over?

  2. JayBMarch 28, 2024

    It probably had more to do with getting those 3 an at bat on opening day than anything to do with the game.

  3. porpoiseboyMarch 28, 2024

    Nice! We no hit everyone but one player

  4. BobbyMarch 28, 2024

    Damn! Seeing Adrian Beltre throw out the first pitch hurt me inside.

    Damn damn damn

  5. Andrew Vincent ForteMarch 28, 2024

    4:10 PM ET

    Cardinals (0-0)

    Dodgers (1-1)

    SP Miles Mikolas R

    0-0 .00 ERA

    SP Tyler Glasnow R

    0-0 3.60 ERA

    Confirmed Lineup

    SS Mookie Betts R

    DH S. Ohtani L

    1B F. Freeman L

    C Will Smith R

    3B Max Muncy L

    LF T. Hernandez R

    CF James Outman L

    RF J. Heyward L

    2B Gavin Lux L

    67° Wind 9 mph Out

  6. BlutoMarch 28, 2024

    Totally a side conversation and unrelated to baseball but IF you have kids in middle school or lower (or grandkids) you have to read the new Jonathan Haidt book:

    The Anxious Generation

  7. CassidyMarch 28, 2024

    No one on mlb network is picking Dodgers to win WS. NO ONE! If we needed any more motivation.

  8. Singing The BlueMarch 28, 2024

    There’s a great article in The Athletic today with regard to how the Dodger front office played the off season. Some excellent detail on how they got Shohei, YY and Glasnow and how it all came together.

    The Glasnow deal was actually helped along by Brad Paisley.

    Anyway, for those who subscribe, take a look for it, authored by Rosenthal/Ardaya.

  9. Brian PerkinsMarch 28, 2024

    Optimist. We win it all and go back-to-back in 2025.

    If not, Dave Robert can swing from deez nutz.

  10. dodger dadMarch 28, 2024

    watching mlb network. last night, jake peaby picked the friars to win the west. matt v. picked the giants. the dodger hate runs rampant! yu darvish is 37 years old. musgrove hasn’t been the same pitcher he was 2 years ago,& cease had an era of around 4 last season. logsn webb is a workhorse. snell walks 5 a gsme and pitches 5 innings a game. the rest of the rotation is an unknown. the dodgers get walker b. back in the not too distant future. glasnow is going to be special! bobby miller is a beast in waiting! stone could do possibly be rookie of the year, and clayton is in the wings. sheehan is about to start throwing soon. yamamoto will be ok. enough said! projecting 110 homers from the big 3. happy for will smith! my prediction for Gavin Lux. 21 homers ,60 rbi,288 average, and 20 sb. not too shabby for s #9 hitter!! MARK it down! (get it ? mark)

  11. Andrew Vincent ForteMarch 28, 2024

    My hopes for the 2024 Dodger season is that we make the playoffs, not concerned with winning the Division and have the team in October with healthy,hungry motivated players ready to win a World Series Championship. Nothing less will be accepted for spending one billion plus. Also I hope AF will make the team as strong as possible at the trading deadline by using prospect capital to fill its needs.

  12. Mark TimmonsMarch 28, 2024

    If in the next two or three years, one of Cartaya, Rushing, or Liranzo can step up and be a “workhorse catcher,” Will Smith could go to another position… or DH and also be the backup catcher. That would be cool.

  13. Mark TimmonsMarch 28, 2024

    This year’s bold prediction: Mookie Betts will have the highest WAR season of his Dodgers tenure. The bar is high — he was worth 8.3 WAR by both Baseball Reference and FanGraphs a year ago, and he’s in his age-31 season. But he’s coming off an MVP-caliber offensive campaign, and if his glove is able to handle the move to shortstop, the positional adjustment could help him rack up more value. It’s already bold that he’s playing shortstop now. But what if he makes the decision look like a no-brainer? — Fabian Ardaya

  14. TherealtenMarch 28, 2024

    Agreed!!

    Smith , Muncy, could have gone elsewhere but wanted to remain a Dodger!! They are not the top tier superstars like say Ohtani, Betts, etc but they provide great value and great leadership to a team. If he bounces back I am very interested to c what Buehler does.

  15. Old Bear 48March 28, 2024

    Good stuff Mark. I am of the mind that the defense is not going to be as bad as most might think. The outfield is in good shape. Rojas will start against some lefties, and the Cards are starting two lefties this weekend. Lux’s OPS against LHP is under .600. The bench is decent, Barnes is who he is. Good defense, weak stick. But once in a while he will surprise you. Taylor and Kike are the Swiss Army knife brothers. They can play most anywhere. The only bench concern I would have is that there is not a thumper coming off of the bench. Taylor has 20 homer power, but in a pinch, he and Kike do not provide a lot of pop off of the bench. Of course, there will be days when any one of the three starting outfielders will be coming off of the bench. I think they will win the division comfortably. But the playoffs can be tricky. I expect Az to give them some problems now and then, same with the Pads. But we will have to wait and see just how all of the Giants new players fit in. Here is a quirk to the season, After July 25th, when they finish a 4-game set against the Giants at Dodger Stadium, they do not play SF again for the rest of the season. This is one reason I dislike the way the schedule is set up now. They only have 15 games against teams from their own division after that Giants series the rest of the season.

  16. sbuffaloMarch 28, 2024

    Glad to see they extended Will Smith. I’m guessing he plays some third base in the future.

    The Dodgers have suddenly gone from a team with mostly short term contracts to a team that will be around for awhile. It’s like the days of Cey, Garvey, Lopes and Russell. Really enjoyed those days.

    But with the long term deals for Betts and Ohtani, some are already wondering how the team will age. We’ll probably hear more talk about windows. Not certain the Dodgers actually have a window. Some good talent coming up through the farm system.

More from Dodger Talk

Nothing Wrong With Back of the Rotation SP for LAD

I said it when Roki Sasaki was struggling…If not Roki, who? He finally started to pitch with more confidence and he put together a string of positive starts. Yes, there were those who forgot about his previous four excellent starts and instead focused on his CWS start. He is a…

By Jeff Dominique · June 16, 202670

Who Bats Where?

A good percentage of comments on this blog relate to “who bats where” in the batting order. “Shohei should bat cleanup.” “ Freddie should be the number three hitter.” “No, Freddie should hit second.” “Max Muncy should hit cleanup.” “Mookie should hit 9th.” … and on and on… Where…

By Mark Timmons · June 15, 2026104

Happy, Hopeful, Blessed, and Thankful

I grew up in Ohio and lived there until 1976, when I was 23 years old. I have been in Indiana for 50 years, so I consider myself a Hoosier. Now, I actually live 45 minutes from Bloomington, where the IU Hoosiers play. However, since I was nine years old, I have been a Dodger…

By Mark Timmons · June 14, 2026123

Are You True Blue?

What do I mean by true blue? Well, over the years I have seen my share of bandwagon and fair-weather fans. True blue fans stick with the team no matter what. Their allegiance to the team never waivers. Not when a favorite is traded or lost to free agency, not when the team…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · June 13, 202693