SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Austin Barnes is not the Problem

It seems that a large number of Dodger fans are seemingly enraged when Austin Barnes catches. Yes, he is no Will Smith. “ Will Smith is an All-Star who hits and throws out baserunners .” They go berserk whenever Will Smith is not in the lineup. In their minds, every time that…

By Mark Timmons3 min readJump to 111 comments

It seems that a large number of Dodger fans are seemingly enraged when Austin Barnes catches. Yes, he is no Will Smith. Will Smith is an All-Star who hits and throws out baserunners.” They go berserk whenever Will Smith is not in the lineup. In their minds, every time that Dave Roberts makes out a lineup card with Austin Barnes’ name on it, they assume that the Dodgers are throwing in the towel. They suffer from BDS (Barnes Derangement Syndrome). Here are just a few things they say:

  • “Barnes can’t hit.”
  • “Barnes can’t throw.”
  • “DFA Barnes”
  • “Call up Hunter Feduccia.”
  • “Roberts is an idiot for playing Barnes.”

Uh, no… you might be the idiot! 😉 The Dodgers record when Austin Barnes catches this season is 13-7, which is a .650 winning percentage. When Will Smith catches, it is 25-16, which is a .608 winning percentage. Now, if Barnes’s record as the starting catcher was 7-13, you might have something… but you have nothing. Zero. Zilch, Nada! As of today, it turns out that the Dodgers have a better chance of winning with Barnes in the lineup over Smith. Maybe this gives you a little insight into how we create imagined problems in our heads and develop a whole narrative that is simply not true.

This is a public service announcement from your always friendly and politically correct blogger, who is tired of Eric’s boorish behavior. If I am as bad as he fantasizes I am, why not just go away? I hate to do it, but blocking him is next.

Yesterday’s Games

  • Gavin Stone continues to impress as he is 6-2 with a 2.90 ERA. What a difference a year makes!
  • Ditto with Michael Grove. He is becoming a valuable innings eater.
  • Alex Vesia: Anyone want him gone now?
  • It turns out that Freddie Freemans’ alleged demise is bullshit. His bat speed is still top 5 in MLB.
  • Feel free to disregard the OKC Baseball Clubs series in Albaquacky. They won 13-2 yesterday. The Isotopes are a horrid team (17-40) in a ballpark that dramatically inflates statistics. Forgetaboutit!
  • Diego Cartaya‘s batting average is up to .211/.692 OPS.
  • Lucas Wepf remains filthy at GL! 1.85 ERA/24 IP/11 H/35 K/0.78 WHIP – You might see him in OKC this year.

X-Cites

Means very little!
https://twitter.com/dodgers_360/status/1797412366025670890

Discussion (111)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. MattJune 5, 2024

    Holy He!! you would think this team is 23-40 and 12.5 games back in the division.

    I get it man it sucks to lose and no one likes losing 1-0.

    But cmon this is a 162 marathon and then a 5 week sprint.

    Settle down, have a beer and relax.

    This team WILL be in the playoffs and the team you see on 6.5.24 will NOT be the team that starts game 1 of the NLDS at Dodger Stadium.

    Stick with these guys they are good and they are going to be damn good come October.

    Mookie has won 2 WS, Freddie has won 1 WS… let me ask you a question, how many WS titles does Harper have, have many does Judge have, how many does Stanton have, how many does Cole and Nola have???

    Ill take Mookie and Freddie over those guys anyday…..

  2. Roger askewJune 5, 2024

    Upon further review., Dodgers lose tonight yet they are 7, 7!!! Games up with a team not even close to full strength and all I’m seeing is a bunch of arm chair managers wanting to make moves in June. JUNE!!! Good God, adjust your way too tight tighty wighties and just relax!! Feel like Mark is spending WAY too much time defending himself and talking half you cats off the ledge. Celebrate where we are at right now, best is yet to come, lose the negative vibe, damn we are so spoiled!!

  3. Roger askewJune 5, 2024

    My God, now idiot posters are calling him Notani because he’s not hitting .800. Where in the HELL did all these Dodger poser smiling bitch face fans come from, it’s like overnight , like cockroaches. Dude has been dealing with a bad hammy going on two weeks , he’ll be just fine. As will the rest of the team, not even close to full strength with injuries, not hitting all that well , but still ok first place by 5 or 6 games! My biggest problem this season is not the team, it’s the new generation of Dodger fans with all the social media bullshit that live game by game and just criticize the hell out of Doc or any player who fell short that day. Not the fan base I’m used to, not even close. If you’re going to spew your 5 second toxic snapshot on how the Dodgers are so terrible in so many ways, buy a damn Giants hat and start hanging with Farhan. Damn…..

  4. BlutoJune 5, 2024

    The comments get SO fucking stupid after losses.

    It’s mind-boggling.

  5. CassidyJune 5, 2024

    And it just gets more pathetic’er for our offense. Highlight was the first inning. AF, you cheaped us out at 1.3 bil!

  6. TherealtenJune 5, 2024

    Will the dodgers score a run this series?

    Skeenes tomorrow/will the Dodgers get a hit?

    How many times can we get a runner on second with nobody out and can’t score?

  7. NorcaldodgerfanJune 5, 2024

    $320 million doesn’t buy what it use to in this present day economy. Pathetic and inexcusable.

    100% agree with NJ Dodger. This team goes through the motions with no emotion. Freaking throw a bat, get thrown out for arguing after a rookie HP umpire calls strike three to an established big league star like Freddie Freeman on a pitch clearly out of the zone.

    0-12 RISP. Why did CT3 get a start?

    Great question by NH Dodger about Ohtani. He does seem to be anrms only on swings as his lower half timing is way off. His ass and front leg are not in sync.

  8. NH DodgerJune 5, 2024

    1. The decision to play Taylor and not Vargas is collaborative. If AF thought it was important for Vargas to get these at bats, Vargas would be playing. I share the frustration. The so-called runway for these “talented young guys in our system” as Brandon Gomes said last year is now about a foot long. Really hard to explain. Certainly, the Dodgers have their reasons but difficult to discern.

    2. For those who watched Ohtani with the Angels, has his swing always been this rotational? Seems to be swinging with a lot of body turn. Plus, he appears to be chasing out of the zone frequently.

    3. In support of what Mark said about batting averages around baseball, I was looking at outfielders that might be potential trade targets and there were several names I looked up and the averages were .180 to .225 for almost all of them. A lot of teams are playing guys who don’t hit particularly well. Which makes the Vargas decision even more puzzling.

    4. I disagree that Kershaw coming in to face Soto in Nats series up a run was wrong only after the fact. It was the wrong move before he threw a pitch. Told my son before the Soto home run that Adam Kolarek made more sense given his success against Soto.

    5. Can somebody tell me what the professional comps are for Rushing? Be the first to admit I am not a scout or talent evaluator but just curious what his ceiling is since he is at AA already and does not seem to be putting up numbers any better than Vargas and Pages did at his age.

  9. NJ DodgerJune 5, 2024

    60yr dodger fan. 1st time poster long time follower

    I deleted my post because it’s the first time I have ever posted and inadvertently put my name in.

    So cut the bullshit on “Several posters posted and then deleted what they wrote because it was Bullshit.” I’m the several. (1post/1 delete

    What I wrote wasn’t bullshit “ look at tonight’s current box scores for tonight’s games and you will see the bottom 4 hitters for the Yankees and the Phillies are both CURRENTLY doing better then the bottom 4 current dodger hitters.

    Of course that can and probably will change

    But I digress,

    Lived in NJ all my life

    Have had the ability to watch many of the Phillies and Yankee games throughout the season.

    Here is the problem the Yankees and Phillies have heart/life, they are aggressive and they are as you would call it “junk yard dogs”

    And they do not let up.

    The Dodgers, especially the leaders , Mookie , Freddy and Othani are nice guys.

    Watch the Yankee/ Dodger games this weekend. Tell me who you would want in a foxhole with you when the shit hits the fan or who you want up with runners in scoring positon.

    Love my Dodgers but don’t love the make-up of this team. They really do not know how to develop young offensive talent. On the other hand they do a tremendous job on developing pitchers.

    Go Dodgers

  10. CassidyJune 5, 2024

    Pages over Vargas. Interesting. Fail!

  11. NorcaldodgerfanJune 5, 2024

    Dodger offense is utterly pathetic right now. Hitting with RISP is non existent, when Freddie gets hot Mookie and Ohtani go ice cold.

    I’ve not agreed when others have posted that CT3 should be DFA’d but it’s time.

    Something needs to happen to send a message to the sleep walking hitters whether that’s RVS being let go, DFA for CT3, more playing time for Vargas. I have no idea but to see this team struggle offensively is mind boggling.

  12. dodgerdadJune 5, 2024

    Taylor needs to go!!!!! Why is pages or vargas not playing???? this is like being constipated!! can’t do sh*t!!!!!!!

  13. TherealtenJune 5, 2024

    A .180 hitter called up today batting 9th hits a homer.

    Our 700 million dollar man is turning into Mr. K. That is why we have to have somebody to put it in play. Wouldn’t u know Freeman is looking better and Ohtani and Betts awful.

    This offense is hard to watch. 1 run looks like 20. Kkkkk and kkk…this game is so hard. Betts usually gives u a good at bat. He swings at strikes and lays off bad pitches. Ohtani can’t do that . As an investment I c the money. As a player he needs to be pitching for the Dodgers to get their money’s worth.

  14. MichaelJune 5, 2024

    You’re an expert and one might think it’s your job at making everything seem rosy with this team and nothing wrong with that. Myself I wouldn’t bet a nickel on this team if playoffs started today but I sure hope that changes

  15. dodgerdadJune 4, 2024

    i’m sorry, but does anyone get that warm and fuzzy feeling hitters 6-9? Glasnow. has to pitch a perfect game to have a chance to get a win!! Sorry, not being negative, just honest!

  16. MichaelJune 4, 2024

    Dodgers 7 thru 9 hitters are 29th in OPS so not only are Phillies and Yanks better so are 27 other teams

  17. TherealtenJune 4, 2024

    I hope Taylor does go 2-4. Mb he is trying to get Taylor set up for a trade.

    I would really love to c Vargas get an extended chance. His plate discipline, speed , and bat to ball skills look good. The mental side? I keep reading how it really hurt him mentally in his struggles last year. He doesn’t look smooth in the outfield. I am wondering out loud why he is not getting a long runway.

    Kiké would be the easiest to trade. Low salary, had interest from other teams earlier. Can’t hit righties. He is helpful defensively but so is Taylor. Both can get the big hit in a big moment or not.

    If we get on a win streak and the bottom of the lineup trends up I hope AF doesn’t think all is solved. This is not a playoff offense. Best lineup: vs righty

    Betts

    Ohtani

    Freeman

    Smith

    Muncy

    Teo

    Heyword

    Vargas

    Lux

    Against lefties

    Betts

    Ohtani

    Smith

    Freeman

    Teo

    Muncy

    Pages

    Vargas

    Rojas

  18. dodgerdadJune 4, 2024

    Patience my brothers!!! Nobody knows what the hell is going on!! There must be a higher power guiding Doc’s decisions. We will know the answer soon enough! Although i am completely bumfuzzled as to why Taylor is starting!! But he’ll probably go 2 for 4 and make a couple outstanding catches!! Patience!!!

  19. MichaelJune 4, 2024

    The way they’re treating Vargas is just plain wrong and pisses me off honestly. My eyes tell me the kid can hit better than the most of bottom of lineup yet they won’t give him a chance

  20. Andrew Vincent ForteJune 4, 2024

    Good News:

    Just checked the box score from the ACL from last night where the Dodgers won 9-5 and River Ryan is back rehabbing there. His line 2IP 0R 0ER 1BB 5K Also possible shortstop of the future Joendry Vargas number one signing in the 2023 International Draft hit his second homerun.

  21. Andrew Vincent ForteJune 4, 2024

    6:40 PM ET

    Dodgers (38-23)

    Pirates (27-32)

    SP Tyler Glasnow R

    6-3 3.04 ERA

    SP Jared Jones R

    3-5 3.55 ERA

    Confirmed Lineup

    SS Mookie Betts R

    DH S. Ohtani L

    1B F. Freeman L

    C Will Smith R

    LF T. Hernandez R

    RF J. Heyward L

    2B Gavin Lux L

    3B Miguel Rojas R

    CF Chris Taylor R

    84° Wind 6 mph In

  22. Old Bear 48June 4, 2024

    MLB banned Padre’s infielder, Tucupita Marcano for life for betting on baseball. While a member of the Pirates, he placed over 380 bets on baseball. 25 of those on the Pirates while he was a member of the organization. Four other players received one-year bans. Andrew Saalfrank of the D-Backs is probably the only name you would recognize,

  23. Mark TimmonsJune 4, 2024

    Watford,

    What manager would not have allowed Clayton to start in light of the fact that since he was re-activated on August 10th, he pitched 37 innings and allowed 9 Earned Runs. That’s a 2.18 ERA? 6 of them were solo HRs.

    If Roberts hadn’t pitched him, and the Dodgers lost, he would have been crucified and because he pitched him, he is crucified. I know you are not Roberts Basher, but see how easy it is to criticize any move?

    I think, given all the circumstances, every manager in baseball would have had to start Clayton.

    Now, I thought he might only make it two or three innings…

  24. TherealtenJune 4, 2024

    When Kershaw was in his prime the Dodgers tried to win the playoffs with 1 pitcher. Him and Grienke were together to make 2. Generally, he was over used as ownership went the cheap route using guys like Anderson, McCarthy etc last year we had no pitching and Kersh shouldn’t have been out there but really no good options.

    This year should be different with much better options. My concern would be their love affair with Buehler. When Scherzer came over Buehler was game but had lost his best stuff. He was pitched in the biggest games but just didn’t have it. To me, it was obvious he wasn’t right then but the chess players saw different. Buehler wants the ball but he should not get it based on reputation. If he deserves it sure but right now he doesn’t. Thankfully Urias is not here to over pitch like they did in the Atlanta debacle.

    Right now if the playoffs started today:

    Glasnow

    Yamamoto

    Stone

    Buehler

    But I bet Stone and buehler would be switched. Kershaw coming back will provide an option. If he is healthy I could c them starting him in the playoffs deserving or not. Miller, idk to me he has the best stuff but his lack of swing and miss is puzzling.

  25. CassidyJune 4, 2024

    Last year doesn’t count because Kersh was injured and we had no other good options. But you’re right, Kersh just hasn’t performed anywhere near his regular season self in October. But how often have we had 4 reliable starters in October. He has had to pitch on short rest in many series in October. What really irks me is that he was brilliant in game 1 against Houston in 17 and if not for the trash cans in game 5, he probably would have been MVP of the series. And true to who he is, Kersh has always owned up to his October failures. No excuses. And I’m rooting for him to have a final, successful October send off!

More from Dodger Talk

Dodgers Food Trailer

I did this interview a couple of weeks ago with Chef Mike, who runs the Dodgers Food Trailer for the Great Lakes Loons. They are there for every home and road regular season and playoff game. They prepare three meals a day for approximately 50 people (players and coaches). Since games end late most evenings, they do not prepare breakfast. Many of their hotels have a complimentary breakfast anyway. However,…

By Mark Timmons · July 17, 202673

Meet LAD 2026 Draft Picks 1-12

3 picks were High School players (2 SS and 1 OF). There was a college OF, college catcher, college SS, and 10 college pitchers. Of all the talk for a need for a catcher, the only catcher the Dodgers selected was Luke Bard, son of LAD bullpen coach Josh Bard. Bard was a 4th year senior from Houston Christian University. He is not a prospect, so the Dodgers are still…

By Jeff Dominique · July 16, 202674

Interview with Paul Beachy – Team Bus Driver For The Great Lakes Loons (LA Dodgers Minor League Team)

It’s been a few days since I did this interview. We have evidently been working my son-in-law (the video guy) like a rented mule at US Water Systems. However, I am taking him to London with me in a few days, so maybe Watford will buy him a pint as a tip, but he’s a dang Red Sox fan, so there is that! I thought that it would be interesting…

By Mark Timmons · July 15, 202652

Thanks for Your Service: Chris Taylor

I was going to do this post when Chris announced he was retiring, then he changed his mind, but since the chances of him ever playing for the Dodgers again are slim and non-existent, I will go ahead with this post. He unretired, went on the IL, then decided to call it quits on May 24th. Taylor was born in Virginia Beach VA on August 29th, 1990. He attended Great…

By Michael "Bear" Norris · July 14, 202676