SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Time for a New Manager?

You all know that I have had Dave Roberts back since he became the Dodgers’ Manager. Many of you have blamed Dodger’s failures on Roberts – I have put it on the players. Doc is not perfect and has made mistakes, but it is up to the players to execute. Plain and Simple! Let me…

By Mark Timmons5 min readJump to 80 comments

You all know that I have had Dave Roberts back since he became the Dodgers’ Manager. Many of you have blamed Dodger’s failures on Roberts – I have put it on the players. Doc is not perfect and has made mistakes, but it is up to the players to execute. Plain and Simple! Let me preface this with “Managers Have a Shelf Life.” It probably used to be a lot longer than it is now. There comes a point whereby a manager’s voice becomes just “background noise.” There is a point where the players simply tune it out.

Many fans have wanted to fire Dave Roberts for a while now. Some because they do not like his decision-making process, some because he is not a “Real Dodger” and others simply because they simply don’t like him. Personally, I have never wanted Doc fired… until now.

I have no fault with most of his decisions. Well, occasionally, I wonder about some decisions, but what do you expect? That comes with the territory. Dave Roberts is a good man. He is an upright man. Dave Roberts is an underdog… I like that.

Dave and I disagree on politics….and that is OK. Believe it or not, I have lots of Democratic friends (there are also a similar number who hate me – that is their problem… not mine). I have championed Dave Roberts for seven years now. I can’t do it anymore! I really can’t! For the initiated, politics are opinions, not facts. If you think otherwise, you are dumber than a bag of hammers.

But, this is not about politics. It is about the Dodgers. Dave Roberts is even-keeled. Dave Roberts does not get overly excited or worked up. Dave Roberts is a player’s manager. He is laid back and he does not apply pressure to the players. That may have worked for a while, but it ain’t working now.

The Dodgers need a new manager. Doc’s shelf life has expired! He was never really a Dodger anyway! Thank you for your service, Dave Roberts, but it’s over.

You have to let go and Andrew Friedman needs to name an ex-Dodger as the manager. This is really hard, Dave… you are a good man. You are almost the face of the Dodgers… but you are not the Dodgers! This team is playing below expectations. Dave Roberts is a player’s manager, but it’s over! The players need to be held accountable. The Dodger’s lineup is composed of Millionaires… from Mookie Betts, to Justin Turner to Cody Bellinger. We have seen this movie too many times: where everyone hits or no one hits.

Who becomes the Manager?

The individual I am recommending may be the long-term solution. Maybe Chase Utley or Justin Turner could be the long-term solution, but right about now, the Dodgers need a “Kirk Gibson-Type-Solution. They need someone who can light a fire, inspire, push, and maybe even move a player out of their comfort zone. It’s not Mike Scoiscia or Joe Madden either. It’s a man who is a lifetime Dodger. The Dodgers are the only organization he has been involved with in his 50 years on the planet. Travis Barbary is 5′ 9” and 180 and his stocky build is that of a ctacher. Catcher Travis Barbary was undrafted out of the University of Virginia and started his professional playing career with the Ohio Valley Redcoats of the fledgling Frontier League in 1993. He was picked up by the Los Angeles Dodgers organization in 1994 where he hit .178 with 3 2B in 45 AB for the Great Falls Dodgers.

It was decided then and there, that Travis was not MLB material, and his playing career ended. Barbary served as the pitching and catching coach for the Cotuit Kettleers of the Cape Cod League in 1995. In 1996 and 1997, Barbary was a coach for the Savannah Sand Gnats. From 1998-2001, he was the bullpen catcher for the Dodgers. In 2002 he was the hitting coach for the South Georgia Waves.

Barbary was the manager of the Ogden Raptors in 2003-2004. He was manager of the Columbus Catfish of the South Atlantic League in 2005 and 2006. In 2007-2018 Barbary was the Minor League Catching Coordinator for the Los Angeles Dodgers. He was scheduled to manage the Oklahoma City Dodgers in 2020 before the season was cancelled due to COVID-19. Barbary did return to manage Oklahoma City again in 2021 and is currently OKC’s Manager.

Travis Barbary’s first pitching change as OKC Dodgers manager: Removing Clayton Kershaw in his Major League rehab appearance at Chickasaw Bricktown Ballpark on April 4, 2019. Photo courtesy of OKC Dodgers.

Here is a quick interview with Travis when he first took over at OKC.

Players seems to respect and enjoy playing for Travis and I think the fact he bleeds Dodger Blue is nothing but a plus. When you do the same thing over and over again and expect different results, that is the definition of insanity. I understand that a manager managers and players play, but sometimes change is good. Sometimes change is needed. I think this is one of those times. It’s just my opinion and I will not be fixated on it if it doesn’t happen… but I think it is needed.

Disclaimer: None of this will likely happen… but I tried!

Future Dodger Notes & News

  • Mitch White pitched 5.2 hitless innings (he walked 2) and struck out 6. I think he wants a spot in that Dodger Rotation.
  • Garrett Cleavinger pitched 1 inning and dropped his ERA to 2.40. In 25 IP at OKC he has struck out 25 and walked 9. He has recently been cutting down on the walks.
  • Miguel Vargas hit a 2-Run HR (his 10th).
  • Mike Busch Doubled and still is playing LF.
  • Leonal Valera was 2-4 (.379 BA) playing 3B for Tulsa.
  • Gavin Stone proved to be a mere mortal yesterday as he pitch 4 innings, allowed 7 hits and 4 runs to go with 3 K’s and 2 BB.
  • Diego Cartaya was 2-4 with 2 RBI and a BB. He is OPS’ing 1.003 at Great Lakes.
  • Kendall Williams saw his ERA drop to 3.24 as he pitched 3 innings, allowing 1 hit, 0 Runs and striking out 8 while walking no one.
  • Cole Percival looks more and more like a middle reliever as he went 1.1 innings, allowing 1 hit and striking out 2.
  • Damon Keith CF was 2-5 and is still hitting .306.
  • Ronan Kopp (2.63 ERA) pitched 3 innings, allowing just 1 hit 1 BB while striking out 3.
  • Nelson Quiroz – C was 4-6 with 3 HR and 6 RBI’s. In his minor league career he has hit 4 HR – 3 yesterday!

Discussion (80)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review.

  1. Jayne CobbJune 13, 2022

    Interesting analysis on ESPN. I have said all year I am NOT worried about our pitching. Even with Walker struggling (and now injured) and Urias having some bad games. The Dodgers have the arms. What is interesting is this particular correlation. Walk to strikeout ratio seems to quite accurately predict a team’s success. Absent any analysis of offensive numbers.

    ESPN:

    A few weeks ago, baseball statistician Bill James did a study on if controlling the strike zone is as important now as it was in Ted Williams’ day. He came up with a simple formula that pretty accurately predicts a team’s winning percentage based only on walks and strikeouts.

    In his study, he explained that 90 teams had a strike zone winning percentage of .613 or higher, with an average of .638. Their actual winning percentage was .595. The worst 109 teams had a strike zone winning percentage of .363 and an actual winning percentage of .377.

    In other words, knowing nothing about a team other than how well it controls the strike zone is a strong indicator of how good or bad the team is.

    Heading into Sunday’s games, the top three teams in strike zone winning percentage:

    1. Yankees, .629

    2. Dodgers, .627

    3. Astros, .573

    The Dodgers also led the majors in this category a season ago, although their pitching depth will now be tested with the news that Walker Buehler will be shut down for at least six weeks because of a flexor strain in his right elbow. Of course, the Dodgers excel at getting the most out of their pitchers. For example, Tyler Anderson had a career strikeout-to-walk ratio of 2.90 before signing with the Dodgers. Now it’s at 6.11 and he’s gone 7-0 with a 3.07 ERA. Tony Gonsolin is also 7-0, with a 1.58 ERA. So, as expected, the Dodgers’ 1-2 punch is Anderson and Gonsolin rather than Buehler and Julio Urias.

  2. porpoiseboyJune 13, 2022

    Mark, I am sure you have many DEMOCRAT friends, but I hope they are also Democratic. Not one in the same though. Sorry, we all have our pet peeves.

    Personally looking forward to NOT watching every game as downhill mountain bike season is starting up & I will be up on the mountain at least 3 days a week.

    Cheers all

  3. DavidJune 13, 2022

    I think Mark conned you all into ‘agreeing’ with him. I expect his next column to be calling you all dopes, as he posts how the team leads in all offensive and pitching stats. HA HA what dopes

  4. JayBJune 14, 2022

    Reading the posts over the past few days has me shaking my head. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but please try to base those opinions on facts. Here are the Dave Roberts facts:

    1. .621 regular season winning percentage is the best in MLB history. The only other Manager (that managed any length of time) with a winning percentage over .600 was Joe McCarthy.

    2. Been in the post season all 6 years

    3. 3 trips to the World Series (half his years managing the Dodgers), winning one and it could be argued probably would have won the second (2017) if the Astros wouldn’t have known when Kersh was throwing a slider in game 5.

    4. Blessed with great player talent, but no greater than some other Managers (Sparky Anderson, Tony La Rusa, Bobby Cox, etc) had but no other winning percentage came close to Docs.

    Yes he’s made some questionable moves but so has every other Manager/Coach in history. I have been a fan since the late 1940’s. As a 7 year old, I cried when I saw Bobby Thomson hit the shot heard round the world Iive on TV. I’ve watched Dressen, Alston, LaSorda, bunch of guys in the middle (including Joe Torre), and now Roberts. Trust me when I tell you that all the second guessing and complaining in the world doesn’t change the fact he is damn good at what he does. All I can say is take a deep breath, chill and try to gain some reasoning in your approach.

  5. VengeurJune 14, 2022

    Hmmm. I see Roberts is STILL Manager. And Belli is STILL batting two bucks and change. Cuz he didn’t bat today. And the Dodgers STILL lead the division.

  6. Mark TimmonsJune 14, 2022

    … and I may or may not believe all of this.

    Sometimes we need some stimuli!

  7. VengeurJune 14, 2022

    It was a little hard to believe since you come across as a loyal person of firm convictions. And one weekend sweep by the Giants and you wanna pull the plug on Roberts??? Not buying it Boss.

  8. EricJune 14, 2022

    Here is what I would do immediately:

    Bring up Zach McKinstry and send down Eddy Alvarez.

    Bring up James Outman and send down Hanser Alberto.

    Bring up Mitch White and release David Price.

    Bring up Marshall Kasowski and send down Phil Bickford.

    Bring up Ryan Pepiot and send down Michael Grove if he is on the roster, otherwise send down Brusdar Graterol.

    Bench Max Muncy and Justin Turner for awhile, while giving Zach McKinstry and James Outman a shot at starting.

More from Dodger Talk

The Dodger Give Tulsa a Wedgie!

As you have probably heard, Eric Wedge was recently named manager of the Dodger’s AA Affiliate, the Tulsa Drillers. Scott Hennessey was formerly the manager of Tulsa, but he moved up to the OKC Comets last fall after former OKC Manager Travis Barbary decided that he would rather…

By Mark Timmons · January 23, 202537

Who Stays and Who Goes”?

There are thirteen pitchers who love Austin Barnes . He is an “on-the-field-pitching coach.” He is not going anywhere, so get that out of your mind. Hunter Feduccia, who happens to be LH, may or may not be a better hitter, and maybe his arm is slightly better, but he is no…

By Mark Timmons · May 28, 202490

All Gave Some – Some Gave All

On Memorial Day, we all need to pause and be thankful for the United States Military Personnel who died while serving the United States. It’s also a time we can thank the living survivors of foreign wars. Freedom is not free, and we should never take it for granted. Thank You…

By Mark Timmons · May 27, 202452